Child Support & Custody Support Group
This community is dedicated to those involved in child support and custody cases. There are a myriad of challenges involved in any case and this is a safe place to talk about what you're going through with others who may be going through the same. Join the group and seek advice, find or provide a listening ear, or just share your feelings in this support group.
Now if she had a job and was bringing in a paycheck it would be different. I stopped getting child support from my X because he felt like he was paying for my personal things. HA! I work hard for my paycheck and it goes to pay bills and provide for my kids. And if he was supporting me then I would have lost everything and I haven't. But he still thinks that when he sends money for child support it is suppose to be only for his son to buy what he wants. When in reality it is to help raise his son. And what he is suppose to pay in child support barely covers child care. But he thinks he is making my car payment and buying me clothes. This is something that can make a good debate. I have had this discussion with other NC Parents before. Sometimes you just have to let things go no matter how upset they make you. I have had to do that with my X. It sucks when you don't think things are going the way they should. Good luck with it all!
I mean, I could see you paying 50% of what it would cost to take care of your son but if she can actually buy her clothes, food, etc with it, then I think you're paying way too much. I mean, not to come off rude, but welfare will help her get a job and also help pay for child care if that's her issue.
I really look up to ANY father that wants to take care of their kids and it sounds like you do. I wish that my sons were as lucky as yours. Thanks for being a supportive father.
Do you really know all of her sources of income? Parents for instance. Does she get supplemental income such as food stamps? Are you happy with that? Do you want your kid to be hungry instead?
Is it really in your best interest that your kids mother go back to work? Is is the kid better off with a full time parent?
In case you don't know the studies done on that subject the answer is "full time parent".
Would the rent go down if she wasn't living there? Utilities, transportation, etc? Food- OK there's one.
Frankly you should be proud you are able to pay all for your kids needs plus a full time caretaker.
I've thrown a lot at you here, maybe unfairly at times, but its a rare mother getting rich off of child support. More likely she is losing out on job or career opportunities taking care of a kid. Yours.
That being said, I do agree that I am paying also for a full time caregiver since she does take him to and from school and prepare his meals. I say full time but I have him every other weekend and a couple afternoons a week, and I provide his care when he's with me, not her. I must admit I was some what upset by the ridiculous question about letting my child go hungry instead, that's insulting. Buddy I care about my son very much and I would never want to see him suffer in any way, shame on you for suggesting it. What I'm not happy about is the fact that my child is not receiving the full benefit of the child support. I'm not saying she's getting rich either, she could get %100 of my income and not be getting rich.
I think that she should be earning some kind of income to provide for her share of utilities, food, rent (when she finally gets a place), and clothes. I'm sure she's struggling without an income and you kind of prove my point there Priscila, it's not a good living, for him or her. I pay enough to provide a good living for him but due to her supplement her income with his child support. Thanks everyone for the advice to have the amount or custody modified, it's strong advice that i will consider.
Just thought you should know, but if they didn't it is an arguement you could use and win with
she is the primary care taker, meaning, as long as the child is not going without basic needs, or being abused and neglected, why are you complaining? you do not get to dictate what child support is spent on. unless the child is being deprived of shelter, food, clothes, water, electricity, ect. whats the problem? so what she isnt working. how old is the child? i will tell you what i told my husband. do you have any idea what fulltime nannies cost? here is the deal, if she decides she is going to barely make it by living on the child support, nothing you can do as long as the child does not go without basic needs. this smells like someone complaining about paying childsupport, nothing more. seriously, i am willing to bet you are not paying enought to her every month to cover the rent, utilities, car payment, gas, food, clothing, medical, ect. for an adult and a child. if you are, you might want to check into geting that changed asap!
here is a little advice for you, and i am saying this because i have a real problem with people that get child support and then have the nerve to ask for more on the side, if there is a need for more then they should take it to court and show the judge what that need is and let him decide if the payor should have to pay more. when she asks you for money for shoes, school functions, ect. ask here why she didnt buy the child shoes with the child support you sent her. do not give her extra money, trust me on this one, she will continue to bleed you as long as you let her. when you stop giving her extra money, she will start spending that money right AND get off her ass and get a job. if the child is old enough to go to school she really has no excuse for not working.
ex's only do what you allow them to do when it comes to getting more money on the side or interferring with your personal life. as long as you are paying child support, if your child is going without because you do not give her extra money on the side, then you can take her to court and have her explain exactly why the child is going without. the judge will take into account that she lives rent free with her dad, which will really make her look bad for asking you for extra money to get the child the basic needs. i am going to assume you pay between $75-$125 a week, if she cant feed, cloth, buy the child shoes, and get him to school functions on that amount since she doesnt pay rent or utilities, the judge will expect her to explain why not since the money is for the child, not her. another thing, she should not be wasting money on gas to drive him to and from school, gas is like gold now, too high priced for someone who doesnt work, the child can ride the bus, right? i had putting my ss on the bus, he rides for an hr each way, but that is what our taxes pay for, and he has autism, which makes riding the bus a bit overwhelming for him, but, he needs to ride the bus instead of us paying taxes for the service AND paying high prices for gas to get him to and from school.
this really seems like your ex is using you and out of love for your child you are letting her, put a stop to that asap. stop giving her extra money, if she complains dont argue with her, tell her to get a JOB, she is responsible for %50 of supporting the child.
Anyway - if you feel your ex is not providing for your son then you will need to address it. Do you have documented info or situations where your son is going without? I'm sure if you saw this you wanted to step in and help but at the same time its mind boggling why he would be going without if you pay a decent amt of child support & she lives with a parent or something. And if things were that bad, she really needs to get a job. My question would be why doesn't she have a job?
Was the child support & custody arragement worked out in court and is there a court order?
I find it riduclous that some courts allow one parent to be voluntarily unemployed while the other provides 100% of the money for raising the child. I also don't think that being custodial parent should be viewed as a "job". Having a child is a gift and I certainly hope that most parents don't think of child support as pymt for raising the child.
I know people that use the child support in the wrong ways and have admitted it. Even people on here that I've talked to. I don't see why people get so defenisve about it unless they are doing something wrong with it.
For some reason, people really don't value this, and think that any parent who can work, ought to get out there and make some money, no matter what the cost to the child's emotional wellbeing.
I know that lots of people do not have this choice at all. But if the possibility is there, why not let the child benefit? Would it be better to have more cash and more pairs of shoes?
I agree that she should probably not ask you for extra money, even if she needs it, as it just seems to upset you. And it would possibly be nicer if you were the one who got to be with him full time, and not the one making that possible for her, by working.
I think that children who have already been through a difficult event such as divorce, need more attention - not less. Not more money. More time from the adults who support them.
I agree with the point that not working, is also a cost for the person who is not working - I'm paying that cost now in the lack of retirement savings, ability to rejoin the workforce later, and earning capacity if and when I do. But I know I am helping my children.