Multiple Sclerosis (MS) Support Group
This community is a place where members can discuss current events and weigh in on what's going on in the world.
MS Patient Beware - MRI Contrast Poisoning
gasf
A doctor has come out and stated that millions of people are going to need to be followed due to gadolinium poisoning. Gadolinium Based Contrasting Agents (GBCAs) are used for MRIs and MRAs. The FDA has recently issued a black box warning and all GBCAs are on the list. The two worst products are Omniscan (GE) and Magnevist (Bayer). There is a lawsuit.
Please I ask you to consider your exposure. We need to get the general population to look into their exposure because you will likely be sickened from it. Mine was gradual but you can get the disease soon after exposure as well. I had many injections of this toxic heavy metal but I know people worse off than me that have only had one exposure.
This is an explosive issue and you will be hearing a lot more about this disease as millions have been injected.
Author Interview: Jerrold L. Abraham, MD
Co-Authors: Sanyal S, Marckmann P, Scherer
Multiorgan gadolinium (Gd) deposition and fibrosis in a patient with nephrogenic systemic fibrosis--an autopsy-based review.
Sanyal S, Marckmann P, Scherer S, Abraham JL.
Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2011 Mar 25.
What are the main findings of the study?
The distribution of deposits of insoluble Gadolinium (Gd) phosphates resulting from the release of Gd from the chelated form in MRI contrast agents had not been previously studied at the histologic scale other than in skin. This extensive examination of many tissues from an autopsy case of Nephrogenic Systemic Fibrosis (NSF) documents the widespread distribution of such deposits. Most deposits were seemingly related to blood vessels, but intraparenchymal deposits in cells of some organs such as liver were also noted.
Were any of the findings unexpected?
The most surprising finding was the deposition of Gd within cells in the central nervous system (cerebellum). The deposition of Gd has been shown in abnormal brain tissue (i.e., brain tumors) even with normal renal function, but apparently in some cases of NSF the Gd (either in chelated form and/or after release of free Gd from the chelate) is able to cross the Blood Brain Barrier (BBB) in otherwise normal brain tissue. Although we have detected Gd in myocardium in many other NSF cases, none was detected in this case (most likely a result of solubilization of Gd-phosphate deposits during acidic fixation of the heart).
What should clinicians and patients take away from this study?
The widespread distribution of Gd in tissues of NSF patients highlights the need to prevent this disease and also the need for further studies of the mechanisms involved in the reactions to Gd and the complex problem of calcium and phosphate regulation and sequelae in patients with chronic renal failure (CRF) or end stage renal disease (ESRD). For example, the role of Gd itself in promoting calcium phosphate deposition is in need of further study.
Remember that each single standard dose of Gd contrast agent contains approximately 1.5 GRAMS of the element Gadolinium, of which approximately 1% (15 mg) may be retained in the body (mostly in bones) even in persons with normal renal function.
What recommendations do you have for nephrology health care providers as a result of your study?
First, this study reminds the clinician of systemic involvement by this predominantly dermatologic clinical condition. And the systemic involvement (fibrosis in many organs) is associated with widespread gadolinium deposition. Systemic pathologic involvement when present may be subtle and overlap with findings of chronic renal failure. Since this is a rare and disappearing disease, clinicians should keep NSF in the differential diagnosis of systemic clinical findings in a patient with NSF.
Clinicians should become aware of the potential for release of Gd from various MRI contrast agents (both existing and newer ones) and possible long term consequences of accumulation of a body burden of Gd in millions of patients. This will require long term follow up and investigations by many medical scientists.
Multiorgan gadolinium (Gd) deposition and fibrosis in a patient with nephrogenic systemic fibrosis--an autopsy-based review.
Sanyal S, Marckmann P, Scherer S, Abraham JL.
Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2011 Mar 25.
Department of Pathology, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY.
Abstract
BACKGROUND:
Nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF) is a systemic disorder of patients with severe renal insufficiency who have received gadolinium (Gd)-based magnetic resonance contrast agents (GBCAs). The causative association with Gd exposure was strengthened by the demonstration of Gd in various tissues of NSF patients, predominantly at the bulk chemical level. The distribution of Gd at the histologic level of organs other than skin has not been reported previously.
METHODS:
We analysed tissues from an autopsy case with verified advanced NSF by light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy/energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. Furthermore, we reviewed published literature to compare the histological and histochemical findings in NSF patients and chronic renal failure (CRF) patients without NSF.
RESULTS:
Insoluble Gd-phosphate deposits were detected in the skin, liver, lungs, intestinal wall (ileum), kidney, lymph node, skeletal muscle, dura mater and cerebellum of the NSF autopsy case, primarily in vascular walls. Some, but not all, Gd deposits were seen in fibrotic areas. Literature review highlighted that non-specific tissue fibrosis and calcification are frequent findings in tissues of patients with CRF with and without NSF.
CONCLUSIONS:
Vascular and extracellular Gd deposits are found in multiple organs of NSF patients, associated with calcification, and often in fibrotic areas. Gd deposits are not seen in patients with CRF unexposed to GBCAs but rarely may be seen in GBCA-exposed patients without clinical signs of NSF. Apart from diagnostic findings in skin, fibrosis of muscle and dura may be more prominent in NSF patients. Our findings should stimulate further investigation of mechanisms of fibrosis and pathologic calcification.
http://www.hemodialysis.com/author_interview_gd_deposition_in_pt_with_nsf.html
Please I ask you to consider your exposure. We need to get the general population to look into their exposure because you will likely be sickened from it. Mine was gradual but you can get the disease soon after exposure as well. I had many injections of this toxic heavy metal but I know people worse off than me that have only had one exposure.
This is an explosive issue and you will be hearing a lot more about this disease as millions have been injected.
Author Interview: Jerrold L. Abraham, MD
Co-Authors: Sanyal S, Marckmann P, Scherer
Multiorgan gadolinium (Gd) deposition and fibrosis in a patient with nephrogenic systemic fibrosis--an autopsy-based review.
Sanyal S, Marckmann P, Scherer S, Abraham JL.
Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2011 Mar 25.
What are the main findings of the study?
The distribution of deposits of insoluble Gadolinium (Gd) phosphates resulting from the release of Gd from the chelated form in MRI contrast agents had not been previously studied at the histologic scale other than in skin. This extensive examination of many tissues from an autopsy case of Nephrogenic Systemic Fibrosis (NSF) documents the widespread distribution of such deposits. Most deposits were seemingly related to blood vessels, but intraparenchymal deposits in cells of some organs such as liver were also noted.
Were any of the findings unexpected?
The most surprising finding was the deposition of Gd within cells in the central nervous system (cerebellum). The deposition of Gd has been shown in abnormal brain tissue (i.e., brain tumors) even with normal renal function, but apparently in some cases of NSF the Gd (either in chelated form and/or after release of free Gd from the chelate) is able to cross the Blood Brain Barrier (BBB) in otherwise normal brain tissue. Although we have detected Gd in myocardium in many other NSF cases, none was detected in this case (most likely a result of solubilization of Gd-phosphate deposits during acidic fixation of the heart).
What should clinicians and patients take away from this study?
The widespread distribution of Gd in tissues of NSF patients highlights the need to prevent this disease and also the need for further studies of the mechanisms involved in the reactions to Gd and the complex problem of calcium and phosphate regulation and sequelae in patients with chronic renal failure (CRF) or end stage renal disease (ESRD). For example, the role of Gd itself in promoting calcium phosphate deposition is in need of further study.
Remember that each single standard dose of Gd contrast agent contains approximately 1.5 GRAMS of the element Gadolinium, of which approximately 1% (15 mg) may be retained in the body (mostly in bones) even in persons with normal renal function.
What recommendations do you have for nephrology health care providers as a result of your study?
First, this study reminds the clinician of systemic involvement by this predominantly dermatologic clinical condition. And the systemic involvement (fibrosis in many organs) is associated with widespread gadolinium deposition. Systemic pathologic involvement when present may be subtle and overlap with findings of chronic renal failure. Since this is a rare and disappearing disease, clinicians should keep NSF in the differential diagnosis of systemic clinical findings in a patient with NSF.
Clinicians should become aware of the potential for release of Gd from various MRI contrast agents (both existing and newer ones) and possible long term consequences of accumulation of a body burden of Gd in millions of patients. This will require long term follow up and investigations by many medical scientists.
Multiorgan gadolinium (Gd) deposition and fibrosis in a patient with nephrogenic systemic fibrosis--an autopsy-based review.
Sanyal S, Marckmann P, Scherer S, Abraham JL.
Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2011 Mar 25.
Department of Pathology, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY.
Abstract
BACKGROUND:
Nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF) is a systemic disorder of patients with severe renal insufficiency who have received gadolinium (Gd)-based magnetic resonance contrast agents (GBCAs). The causative association with Gd exposure was strengthened by the demonstration of Gd in various tissues of NSF patients, predominantly at the bulk chemical level. The distribution of Gd at the histologic level of organs other than skin has not been reported previously.
METHODS:
We analysed tissues from an autopsy case with verified advanced NSF by light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy/energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. Furthermore, we reviewed published literature to compare the histological and histochemical findings in NSF patients and chronic renal failure (CRF) patients without NSF.
RESULTS:
Insoluble Gd-phosphate deposits were detected in the skin, liver, lungs, intestinal wall (ileum), kidney, lymph node, skeletal muscle, dura mater and cerebellum of the NSF autopsy case, primarily in vascular walls. Some, but not all, Gd deposits were seen in fibrotic areas. Literature review highlighted that non-specific tissue fibrosis and calcification are frequent findings in tissues of patients with CRF with and without NSF.
CONCLUSIONS:
Vascular and extracellular Gd deposits are found in multiple organs of NSF patients, associated with calcification, and often in fibrotic areas. Gd deposits are not seen in patients with CRF unexposed to GBCAs but rarely may be seen in GBCA-exposed patients without clinical signs of NSF. Apart from diagnostic findings in skin, fibrosis of muscle and dura may be more prominent in NSF patients. Our findings should stimulate further investigation of mechanisms of fibrosis and pathologic calcification.
http://www.hemodialysis.com/author_interview_gd_deposition_in_pt_with_nsf.html
They use MRIs with contrast on MS patients quite frequently but it is going to change as I believe a total ban on the product is forthcoming. If you had one with contrast it would be prudent to do more research and you are welcome.
Sorry I am trying to read & understand but struggling sometimes. If it is it sure needs some following up for sure. Haven't heard anything here about it.
Scary stuff.
I am doing chelation to get rid of the metals and are not getting near an MRI machine unless absolutely necessary.
I'll never get another one, never. This is the one gift you get if you don't mess with the drugs.
Remember 1% of every dose stays in the body and a doctor that is an expert witness in the litigation is saying that millions will need to be followed.
I will never get another one. I would rather have cancer, I am that sick.
Please tell me how this drug has made you sick! I have had more MRI's than I can count! With and without contrast!
Why is it when you switch doctors, they want their own MRI done? They can't just look at the old ones. Since my MS has taken a turn for the worse, I am anxious to know how sick it makes you. What symptoms or conditions does it present with?
Thanks Marilyn
Severe weakness in my legs
Severe muscle pain in my legs and arms
Muscles in my arms feel like rocks
Mental impairment
Burning sensation in my arms, legs, hands and feet
Adrenal insufficiency most likely caused by infiltration of my hypothalamus by gadolinium
Dizziness and nausea
Skin texture changes
It's basically a disease of fibrosis so anything can be impacted. Gadolinium gravitates to damaged tissue so if you have lesions in you brain guess what? It will attach itself there. Of course all of this is not medical advice and you should do your own research but send me a private message and I'll point you to a patent by a doctor that talks about MS patient. I'll try and post it under my journals but I'm having trouble getting anything to post there. Look at the pictures under my profile.
I'm new here. Hope you don't mind if I skip the intro and niceties...I'm feeling so sick and am to get an MRI with contrast tomorrow. After reading this thread I'm now scared to death to get the contrast. But I'm also worried they won't see something if it's there and I want them to see something if indeed it's there! I'm so confused. I called the place I'm getting it and they've never heard of any problems or lawsuits...go figure! They're using multi-hance. But I suppose it doesn't matter which brand of the stuff.
So, can they see if I have MS if I don't get the contrast?
If not, is there some other way to diagnose?
Ok, so someone said if you drink a lot of H20 you'll be ok. Is that for sure????
Thanks very much, Sending a wish to all of you for feeling well!
L
gasf....some of the symptoms that you have I just have associated with MS, like severe muscle spasms/tightness.....so how can you tell what symptom is caused by what problem. I never know if I am having a problem that is MS or something else. I hate MS....duh! This 100+ heat here in SC is killing me!!!!!!!!! I am so thankful for AC!!! I need a perscription for a pool!!!!!!! Really!!
marilyn I'm sorry if this response is too late but if you go to my profile and download Robbie Booker vs. GEHC it will scare them into knowing the truth. Multi Hance is a macrocyclic gadolinium based contrasting agent so is suppose to be safer but they are all on the FDA list.