The effects of alcohol on muscle growth
Life is full of choices. You want alcohol and you want gains, but alcohol hurts your gains. To decide if alcohol’s worth it for you, you need to know how bad the damage is. We did the research. Here’s the answer.
As with any good story, we should start at the beginning. And just like life itself, the story of alcohol and muscle growths starts in the male testicles.
Testosterone is good for your gains: it directly tells your muscle cells to grow [2, 3].
Unfortunately, alcohol is not good for your testosterone if you’re a man. Alcohol, primarily, acetaldehyde, is directly toxic for the testosterone-producing Leydig cells in the testicles. Yes, that’s your balls. In the long run alcohol’s toxicity might even cause a man’s testicles to shrink, which directly reduces their capacity to produce testosterone. Also, chronic alcohol abuse may decrease the brain’s signal to the testicles to produce testosterone [2].
Alcohol can also increase the conversion of testosterone to estrogen in the liver [2], which leaves less of it in circulation.
Alcohol is toxic for your balls and can cause more of your testosterone to be converted into estrogen.
Surprisingly then, light drinking of around 1-3 US drinks actually increases testosterone in the hours thereafter [2].
Now, before you start mixing your post-workout whey in whiskey, higher doses of 4-8 drinks will lower testosterone levels by 18 to 40% [2, 3]. Your testosterone normally recovers within a day from this kind of cocktail party [2, 3].
Alcohol can also impair growth hormone production.
Now if you get yucky with the boyz or girlz fo’ real, the damage can be much worse. A drinking spree of 9+ US glasses of alcohol may instantly tank your testosterone levels by 45%. The next day there may still be a 23% dent in your manly hormones. This level of decrease in testosterone is comparable to being in contest prep for male natural bodybuilders: see the infographic below.
The acute effects are comparable to the chronic effects of daily alcohol consumption: see the following research summary. Up to a few drinks a day will have a small effect on your hormones with a less than 10% decrease in testosterone. When you get into the double digits on a daily basis, testosterone drops considerably by 25-55%, but it’s safe to say you have more serious issues than your gains at that point.
The effect of alcohol consumption on testosterone levels in men.
On a side note, if you love running to the bar after work: doing exhaustive cardio before binge drinking may further prolong the depressing effects on testosterone.
A decrease in testosterone is obviously not desirable in general, but how exactly does this affect muscle growth? Testosterone tells your muscles to grow via the mTOR signaling pathway in your muscles [2]. Since alcohol decreases testosterone levels, it then shouldn’t be a surprise that alcohol decreases mTOR kinase activity, a key enzyme that integrates signals for muscle growth [2, 3]. It then also shouldn’t come as a surprise that muscle growth itself is impaired after alcohol consumption. Specifically, 9 servings of alcohol post-workout decrease myofibrillar protein synthesis (MPS) by 24%.
How bad is a 24% decrease in myofibrillar protein synthesis? As a reference, going from maintenance energy intake into a 40% energy deficit along with a 0.1 g/kg/d decrease in protein intake (1.3 vs. 1.2) has been found to result in a 36% decrease in myofibrillar protein synthesis. So getting wasted on a night out probably has a comparable effect on your muscle growth as if you spent that day cutting.
Alcohol’s effects on testosterone, mTOR and MPS are comparable to its effects on recovery after exercise. Light drinking up to 3 US consumptions doesn’t seem to affect recovery from even very muscle-damaging exercise at all.
Around 4 US consumptions did not affect strength recovery but did lower testosterone.
Alcohol is commonly regarded as being just as bad for women as for men. However, the hormonal problems of alcohol in men all start because alcohol is toxic for the testes. Women don’t have testes (citation needed?). So, why would alcohol be bad for women’s hormones?
It’s not. In fact, multiple studies show drinking alcohol increases testosterone in women [2, 3, 4] and drinking more alcohol is associated with higher overall testosterone levels.
Alcohol is also good for estrogen levels. And in contrast to common belief, estrogen is actually nothing but beneficial for muscle growth, especially in women. Light drinking doesn’t have much effect, but 4-7 drinks can increase estrogen acutely by up to 66% [2, 3, 4, 5].
Now, while these increases in sex hormone levels may be good for your gains, they are related to liver toxicity that causes a disruption in hormonal metabolism. So they’re not good effects in a healthy sense.
In the long term, drinking at least 5 glasses of alcohol per week is associated with higher overall estrogen levels in women [2, 3]. Other research finds it’s testosterone rather than estrogen that’s positively associated with drinking 2-3 glasses of alcohol per day. The following infographic summarizes the literature on the relation between alcohol consumption and estrogen levels.
The effects of alcohol consumption on estrogen levels in women.
Since alcohol is actually good for testosterone and estrogen levels in women, does alcohol still reduce mTOR signaling for muscle growth?
Nope. As you can see in the infographic below, several shots of vodka directly post-workout majorly decreased mTOR activation in men but not in women.
So does alcohol interfere with recovery from strength training at all then in women? In contrast to men, up to 6 US servings of alcohol post-workout don’t seem to affect muscular recovery at all [2].
In men, alcohol reduces testosterone production because alcohol is toxic for the testicles. This effect corresponds to reduced anabolic signaling, muscle protein synthesis and muscular recovery. The damage greatly depends on the dose of alcohol you consumed. A single glass of wine will do basically zero damage. Up to a few drinks a day, the damage is still small, arguably trivial. A night out of partying will affect muscle growth similarly to if you were cutting in contest prep.
The kind of night where you get completely wasted, end up at a stranger’s house, get asked the next day if you’re this person on Youtube and you have to watch the video on mute because even after taking 4 painkillers you can still hear yesterday’s beat in your skull, that day is also wasted in terms of your gains. Even then though, you can most likely still build muscle and strength the rest of the week.
Women, by virtue of not having testicles, seem to be entirely exempt from alcohol’s gain-robbing effects. Their testosterone and estrogen levels actually increase, there seems to be no reduction in anabolic signaling and muscular recovery seems to be unaffected even after hefty post-workout drinking.
For how alcohol affects fat loss and how to minimize the damage of a night out, read our scientific guide to binge drinking.
Cheers!
Source: http://mennohenselmans.com/the-effects-of-alcohol-on-muscle-growth/
Replies