Physical & Emotional Abuse Support Group
Abuse is a general term for the treatment of someone that causes some kind of harm (to the abused person, to the abusers themselves, or to someone else) that is unlawful or wrongful. No one deserves abuse, period. Abuse can be emotional, physical, or sexual.
Emotionally Abusive Twin Sister...What do I do?
Hello there. This is my first time doing something like this, and I'm admittedly a little bit anxious about it. I apologize in advance if it's a bit incoherent... The problem is, I have no one else in my life that I can turn to with this problem, and I've reached the point that I need to share this with someone to try to figure out what is going on and what to do. I can't take it anymore, and I know the stress of the situation is taking a mental and physical toll on me. My body feels it more and more everyday...
This is about my twin sister. My twin sister and I have always been close. We just turned 27 years old this year, and we're still living together. We know each other's deepest secrets and generally can count on each other through thick and thin. Often it's felt like we only have each other. A couple of years ago, we went through some seriously dark times, including us both being disowned by our mentally unstable and emotionally abusive mother, being stalked by a fake "visa" specialist (since we now live in another country after studying abroad), and then being attacked in our apartment by our drunk landlord and his gang of friends. We've come through a lot together.
The problem is, in recent years, my sister has begun starting random, terrible fights with me seemingly for no reason. This has started ever since we began recovering from the awful things that I mentioned above. It would be one thing if it was like normal sibling fights - we've had those before, naturally, but we always make up afterwards. We've even had really bad fights in the past, but there was a sort of "sense" to those that these recent ones just don't have. In recent years, it's been more like the slightest thing I say, regardless of whether it is relevant or not, even if it's something as simple as, "I'd love to have pancakes today," makes her blow up. And there's very little time to recover from it before the next such blow-up appears.
The most recent example...This morning, we had plans to spend a nice day out together in our favorite place, but while she was doing her makeup in the mirror, she got angry when I mentioned what I wanted to do and started a fresh argument completely irrelevant to what I had said (even though it seemed to trigger her need to start one). We'd also had a similar fight the night before, where something completely irrelevant and seemingly harmless that I'd said set her off.
I think what hurts the most is that she doesn't wait a second - the first thing she'll do when she starts an argument now is attack my weak points, my deepest insecurities. Call me awful names based on them, like "fat hag". Once she told me that the man I'm interested in likes her, not me. It's been a huge blow to my self-confidence, which I already had very little of thanks to the father who left our family for his former wife when I was still a kid - he used to draw ugly pictures of me and my sister and bully us. I know people say that we can't let these things bother us, that it says more about the attacker than it does about us, but my twin knows those are my insecurities, and she knows more than anyone how much such words can hurt me. Of course she screams all of these things at me, usually while laughing or flipping me off.
If I try to ignore her, she will threaten to punch me or kick me, raising a fist or actually kicking something near me so I get the message. Sometimes she actually has hit me, without warning. Other times, she will threaten to break my things. She often goes first for my computer and lifts it up as though preparing to smash it. Other times, she'll spit into a bottle of old water and threaten to dump it on me or delicate things I own (again, such as my computer)...All of this if I won't listen to her and keep up the arguing. So unfortunately, trying to take the high road of ignoring it hasn't worked.
I've also tried to keep a calm voice, even when my heart is pounding, and to ask her if we can talk it out. It just doesn't work. She can't seem to keep calm and will continue to argue as loud as she can. When I suggest that we take turns explaining our feelings, she'll insist on going first, but when it's my turn to explain how I feel, she won't actually allow me to even finish a sentence. It's like it's her way or the highway, even if I try to be reasonable. She knows how to say things that cut straight to the bone - part of the reason our mother disowned us is because of something my sister had said to her while we were still at the house. Our mother had already been being emotionally abusive to us by that time, but I think the final straw of disowning us was because of what my sister said. My mother had once told my sister her words towards others were way too harsh after she had done the same thing to a cousin's girlfriend just for being rude.
Finally, I want to mention, I've also suggested therapy for us. I think we've needed it anyway since the situation with our mother. But my sister refuses to go. I've thought a lot about going by myself and explaining my situation, but the fact is I've never done such a thing and I'm a little scared. I don't have enough confidence in myself, and honestly, I wonder if it even matters? If I'm the only one going to therapy, it's not going to help whatever's happening on my sister's side of things. I'm still going to be experiencing it at home.
I'm just really at my wit's end. I think I want to repair the relationship because we've always been close, and I don't really understand why she can't seem to understand me (or perhaps anyone else) anymore. Even her friends stay away from her - the only friends we share now are the ones that were originally friends with me, and whom I introduced to her. I don't really know any of her original friends... I just don't know anymore, and I need someone else's advice.
(For the record, the only reason I haven't told friends or family about this is because we share both now, and honestly, it would do far too much harm to bring this to any of their attentions. I can't say how angry speaking out about my sister would make her, and I don't really want to find out. I just hope someone outside of our circle can help with this matter, because posting anonymously, she may not know it's me...)
In any case, I think this has been super incoherent, but I want to thank you for your time and for your reading. Any advice would truly be appreciated!
time this morning for a
lengthy reply, but here
are some basic thoughts:
Please go to therapy
yourself, no matter
what your sister does
or doesn't do. Having
said this, it's VITAL that
you work with a therapist
who understands toxic
family dynamics and
whose specialty is
recovery from abuse.
You wrote that your
sister has both threatened
you and has actually already
been violent. Knowing this,
you need to keep in mind
that she is capable of
worse than what you've
already seen. There is
no "reasoning" with her
and it's unlikely that,
even if she ever went
to therapy, that it would
make any significant
difference in her behavior.
For your own safety
and on-going well-being
you need to minimize
interaction with her.
Ultimately, your best
option is to go completely
NO CONTACT. This may
sound harsh but based
on what you wrote here,
that's my (both) personal
and professional opinion.
(I had to go NO CONTACT
with a dangerously toxic
sibling. It was a sad choice
to have to make, but it
helped me begin the
healing process.)
I've run out of time for now.
Please stay SAFE
and look for a
qualified therapist
who can support
you in beginning
Your healing path.
First...
@h.e.a.l.- thank you for taking the time to reply even when you were so busy! I really appreciate it! (And your basic thoughts were most definitely helpful!)
I have not begun therapy yet, as you can probably imagine, but it's something I've seriously added to my to-do list. Thank you for your advice on that! I really am serious about it, whether or not my sister goes. The problem is, I live in a country where the main language is not English, and very few people can speak English. I do speak the country's language to an extent, but I don't think I could convey my situation very well in another language. Finding the words in English alone has been hard enough! Of course, I'm then limited to any therapists who might be able to understand English, and I wonder if they could match the specific qualifications you've mentioned. (Thanks a bunch for that - I wasn't aware that finding a very specific therapist was so important, but it's good to know!) I've considered online therapists too, but I think the physical act of talking out loud really is important. Then there's also the fact that my sister is my twin, and I think that also makes it such a different situation... :(
The other thing, I'm scared to separate from her, although I absolutely understand what you mean and appreciate everything you've said. I've heard about the "no contact" policy. I just don't think it would be possible for us. Or rather, of course it's possible, but it might just hurt us both in a new way. We really depend on each other. That's why fights like these are so unbelievably heart-breaking. We've come through such awful times and helped each other through those times. I fully believe she doesn't want to see me hurt, because why would she have helped me through those times? And yet, if her feelings are hurt even just a trifle (and oftentimes by someone else, not even by me), then it seems perfectly reasonable in her mind for her to throw me under the bus, crush my feelings, my hopes, my dreams, my self-esteem, and anything else she feels about me is in her way.
It's really just so hard to know what to do. In many ways, I can't move forward because this is the foundation my life has been built on - being her twin. (It's a part of every aspect of our lives - our friendships, other relationships, work, etc.) I feel like it needs to be sorted out, but that the connection simply can't be cut. I just don't know...
Thank you for your comment, and again I'm sorry for my delay in replying. It's quite possible that's the case. She complains about other people to me all the time (usually the same people), even when their "offenses" honestly seem quite minor or not cause for being so upset. Often during the times when she's like that, it will turn around and become an attack on me. So I'm sure you're right. The problem is, I wonder if this is a direct result of what we went through those last few years, or whether or not its an emotion she's had all along that was brought out and exaggerated since those experiences happened. I honestly think she sees me as "in her way." As her "copy" (I'm the younger twin). I'm also quieter than her. I don't know how that came about, but I think it's mainly because she's always wanted to do the talking for us (since we were children), and I've always been more of the "path of least resistance" type in that regard. My thought is, however, that this has actually become something of a dangerous sentiment over time. As in, by allowing her to speak on our behalves all the time, just because she's wanted to, I've become something like her toy, or at best, right-hand man. I'm not my own person, in her eyes, is what I mean. Or at the very least, how I feel doesn't actually matter.
I absolutely agree that distance is important. Even a short distance always helps, at least for a little while. The problem is that our lives are built on us being twins, so although the physical act of separating might not be too tough, the actual act of extricating our lives from each others' would be painfully difficult. That, and, I get the sense being separated would only hurt us in a new way. It's just all too complicated. This past year I've worked hard on trying to better myself - to separate myself from situations and look at the other side, to not give up or feel as awful as I used to when I failed at something or had some regrets. I've really been working hard on these, and I've noticed in this last year that I've improved a bit - just baby steps, really, but even that is a miracle, in my mind. These were perhaps some of my bigger flaws. Perhaps my sister is not ready to do that, but it's honestly just been hindering my own progress, perhaps even sending me back, dealing with these fights. My self-esteem, which was always low to begin with, has taken such a hit that I'm not even comfortable being myself anymore. I don't even know who that is!
And yet because we're twins, the answer just isn't simple at all. That's the worst part. It hurts so bad... :(
Hey there - thank you for sharing your own experiences, as well as your own very sound advice. I genuinely appreciate it! I hope things have gotten better with your sibling, too. I'm writing again finally after another fight. I know we have to separate, but like I mentioned in the above two comments, it's just so difficult for us as twins. As I said to MetalPrincess, "The problem is that our lives are built on us being twins, so although the physical act of separating might not be too tough, the actual act of extricating our lives from each others' would be painfully difficult. That, and, I get the sense being separated would only hurt us in a new way." All areas of our lives are so entwined, including friends and relationships - we even WORK at the same place, in the same office!! - that it would be so very difficult to separate from her... Such a terrible situation. :(