Graves' Disease Support Group
Graves-Basedow disease is a medical disorder that may manifest several different conditions including hyperthyroidism (over activity of thyroid hormone production), infiltrative exophthalmos (protruberance of one or both eyes and associated problems) and infiltrative dermopathy (a skin condition usually of the lower extremities). This disorder is the most common cause of...
Ideally, per the treatment guidelines linked below, you would have been taking the lowest possible dose that would have maintained your FreeT4 level near the high end of the range, regardless of TSH
http://www.fpnotebook.com/endo/pharm/AnthyrdDrg.htm
https://www.aace.com/files/hyper-guidelines-2011.pdf
If anything, your endo should have told you to switch to 1.25mg every other day or every third day back in December.
Now, 8 months later, it's clear you are very hypo (sorry).
Please know that, per thyroid textbooks, healthy people have FreeT4 levels near the high end of the range (surprise, surprise) and TSH around 1....and definitely not as high as yours.
I think it would be a good idea for you to stop methimazole and see if your remission is "sticking" in November.
It's almost medical malpractice that you didn't get baseline liver tests before starting methimazole and during treatment.
Both hyper and hypothyroidism can cause elevated liver enzymes so, until your thyroid levels become more appropriate, I wouldn't be surprised if your liver enzymes are off (sorry).
Still, congratulations on what appears to be remission!!!
(BTW - if your FT4 level stays low for many months off methimazole, there's a chance you'll be one of the 20% of Graves' patients who go hypo after remission. I am one of them. If this is the case, it's reasonable to ask the doctor for a small dose of thyroid hormone replacement. The hypothyroidism can be temporary but, just like hyperthyroidism, it needs to be treated)