Harry Potter Fans Community Group

A place for people who like Harry Potter books to meet and get carried away with minute details! Spoiler Alert Many discussions involve details from the latest books and movies!

17 Members

131 Posts

0 Online

No1HarryFan 01/29/2009

That was in the books but got left out?

I would have loved to have seen the cleaning in OOTP. Not just because they missed out the vital locket but I would have like to have seen the de0doxying & all the times Kreacher butted in to pinch things back.

I also think that Ginny being with Micheal Corner should have been mentioned too. ppl who haven't read the books are gonna wonder "What the hell happened there?!" when Ginny & Harry get together in the film

ThePepperMan 01/29/2009

I have long said that the movies are more of a "Favorite passages from the book" sort of thing. I would LOVE it if, in a few years, they could find really good twins to play Harry (triplets?) and do a serial thing, where each chapter or two would be a TV movie!

ThePepperMan 01/29/2009

I think that the fight between Harry and Dumbledore at the end of OOTP was BUTCHERED in the movie. Harry NEEDED to be angry, yelling, throwing things. Dumbledore needed to be calm, reticent, almost humbled, yet an adult in control of himself.

No1HarryFan 01/30/2009

I totally agree with you!

ThePepperMan 02/04/2009

Emma has hinted that Hermione and Ron have that fight scene when he returns (DH), same for the kissing scene during the siege of Hogwarts. I do hope that they do BOTH those scenes justice because they are truly important in their love story. I mean icy stares, hitting (normally I decry hitting as a way to express anger, but it seems truly important to the passage) and all!

Oh, and omitting Doby from GOF was a very bad decision IMHO!

No1HarryFan 02/06/2009

Here here!

Join the Conversation

Posts You May Be Interested In

So numb

Posted by: ariel1989

Last Reply: ThePepperMan 10/16/2018

1

We just got home from Port. St. Lucie. Today was Pa’s funeral. I finally said goodbye to my biggest hero today. It was so hard. My grandmother has started transiting to pass on. She did not make it to the celebration of life yesterday or the funeral today. She is very agitated and doesn’t know who anyone is. She has hospice there 24/7. They have upped her morphine and her medication. They are...
New member

Posted by: Sarina

Last Reply: SunCloudJD 10/17/2018

4

Hi, I'm new to the group. I lost my baby sister, June of this year. I was in a grief group, irl, but due to the circumstances surrounding my sister's death, I was looking for something different. I didn't feel comfortable in the group. I kept feeling as though I had to defend her, and my feelings about what happened

So numb

New member