Infertility Blogger
Lee Trask is an advocate for women dealing with issues of infertility and miscarriage. Having struggled through more than six years of infertility, three miscarriages, and high-risk pregnancy, she is now happy raising her two…
Advertisement
Lamaze vs. The Bradley Method - Which is Right for You?
Posted in Pregnancy by Lee Trask on Mar 14, 2012
Now that I’ve touted the benefits of a childbirth class, let’s compare the two most popular methods, and their differences.

Perhaps the best known of all childbirth classes is Lamaze. Developed in the 1940’s, in France by Dr. Ferdinand Lamaze, this method’s main attribute is distraction from pain. Lamaze is:
- Based on belief that labor requires focus and energy

- Gives mother tools to ease and manage pain as it occurs, and to save energy during periods of non-contraction

- Encourages “distraction”, thinking of pleasant memories to keep mind from focusing on pain

- Encourages changing positions, birthing balls, massage, etc. to allow mother to manage pain

- Teaches communication with healthcare providers so that needs can be met

- Educates parents about epidurals and pain management using painkillers

- Educates parents on complications that might arise during birth and the medical interventions that may be necessary to address those complications

- Inclusive of other options for childbirth
The Bradley Method, also developed in the 1940's by obstetrician Robert Bradley, relies on the main attribute of “controlling” pain:
- Focuses on breathing and relaxation techniques to help mother cope with pain during labor

- Relies directly on the husband/partner for “coaching” during labor

- Teaches nutrition and exercise

- Educates parents on different stages of labor and what to expect during each stage

- Advocates “tuning in” to your body during labor

- Quotes 90% of Bradley trained mothers give birth un-medicated

- Avoidance of any drugs before, during and after labor

- Discusses emergency situations requiring intervention and C-section
There is a great website that can give you more information on birth choices.

Again, you need to reach deep and think about what type of person you are under pressure; because believe me giving birth is stressful, physically, and emotionally. It will bring you to a place physically that you cannot describe (both good and bad;) so don’t let me scare you, even though it hurt like hell, it was the single greatest thing I’ve ever done.

If I could relive any day of my life, any hour, it would be the hours I spent giving birth to my sons. And it will wipe you out emotionally; the anxiety, the joy, sometimes the surprising monster that screams at your husband that you will “twist his face off if he comes near you,” things like that...it does leave you spent.

I can tell you that no matter what class you take, it will HURT, so don’t imagine that any class will give you the super human ability to “control” the pain. The only thing that “controls” (i.e. makes the pain go away) is drugs, so if you think you might want 'em, the Lamaze does accommodate that possibility more than the Bradley. On the other hand, if you are steadfast in your resolve to go drug free, Bradley will give you the foundation.

But remember, no matter what you decide, the ultimate goal isn’t natural childbirth. The ultimate goal is delivering a healthy baby, as easily and calmly as possible, so be open to all that happens along the way.

- Lee

 RELATED FROM AROUND THE WEB



       Send to a Friend     Share This

MORE ARTICLES
CATEGORIES: Overview
CONDITIONS AND COMMUNITIES: Pregnancy

MEMBER COMMENTS
TOTAL COMMENTS: 5 - View All Comments »

Add a Comment
Displaying comments 5-1 of 5
5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?featur...

www.orgasmicbirth.com

not all women get there, but at least all women should now it's possible and they should try to reach it!
By moyinha  Mar 17, 2012
4
One thing that I found missing in this summary (I did not read the two previous ones) is that the focus on birthing must be on delivering a healthy baby.

That has to be priority number one.

Yes, some women do not want any medication, others want to avoid a C section. Those are find goals, but they must be subordinate to delivering a healthy baby.
By ThePepperMan  Mar 16, 2012
3
We went through Lamaze classes. My husband wanted to be present for the birth, and in those days, they did not permit fathers to be present unless they had been through a certified childbirth-preparation class.

I used some yoga techniques too, going absolutely limp and focusing on my breathing during contractions. I was able to get through labor and delivery with only a local anesthetic for the episiotomy.

It is very difficult not to hold your breath and push when you reach a certain stage, but we had been trained for this, so my husband was right in my face, commanding, "BREATHE! BREATHE! BREATHE!" I was able to keep from pushing until we were given the go-ahead

Whichever method you choose, by all means, get SOME kind of preparation training, Going into childbirth without any idea of what is happening would be nightmarish. When you know what to expect and have some options about how to deal with it, you don't feel so helpless or scared. YOU are part of the process.
By madbookworm  Mar 16, 2012
2
It seems Lamaze method is good.
By DrChristopher  Mar 14, 2012
1
I did the Bradley method and was 41 and 46 at the time of the natural birth of my kids with a midwife. The OB I started with was under the impression that only stupid people consider natural childbirth, so I left him, because I did not want anything causing a C-section, and he seemed like he preferred to cause labor at his convenience, not the baby's.
I learned a lot from the Bradley book, and from what I know people who do the hypnobirthing are pleased with the ability to "zen" into the process. I think the lamaze breathing is un-natural and they are determined to get you sold on the hospital un-natural program, where Bradley is orienting you to having a healthy and natural birth.
In short I had a few hours of labor and went home 4-6 hours after birth with support and no real problems at all.
By Olismom  Mar 14, 2012
Got a Question?
 
 
 
 
My Fans
RELATED SUPPORT GROUPS
Pregnancy
(10,637 Discussion Topics)