Primary Care Physician
Dr. Orrange received her BA in Biology at the University of California, San Diego, and a Masters Degree in Health Sciences at the Johns Hopkins University School of Public Health. She received her MD from the USC Keck School of…
FAST FACTS
Advertisement
Female primary care doctors connect emotionally with patients, but are more stressed out
Posted in Medical Mysteri... by Dr. Sharon Orrange on Jul 08, 2010
As a female primary care doctor I read, with interest, results presented at a conference of the World Organization of Family Doctors. The results are important for several reasons. Patients feel more rushed and less connected to their doctors than ever before so it is important to find someone you connect with. Though some studies suggest women connect better emotionally with their patients it takes its toll and women are more stressed out. Lastly, the number of women entering medical school is now higher than men so it is important to see how this will change our medical climate.

The upside from several published reports is that female family physicians tend to engage more emotionally with patients than their male colleagues; the downside is they report more job-related stress.

Patients benefit from having a trusting relationship with their physicians and this is especially important for primary care doctors who form long term relationships and see their patients more often. That deeper relationship, however, seems to carry a burden of greater stress for women physicians, who reported more headaches, sleep difficulties, gastrointestinal problems, and family stresses than their male colleagues.

In a recent survey of 110 family physicians in Canada (70 men and 40 women) there were some interesting findings. Although men saw almost an equal percentage of male and female patients (55% and 45%, respectively), women saw a preponderance of female patients (67% vs. 33% men). Women also reported spending significantly more time with each patient (17.8 minutes vs. 13.3 minutes).

Women engaged emotionally with their patients significantly more often than men, taking the time to “listen carefully, show respect, provide simple explanations of diagnosis and treatment, and allow time for questions.” Women also were significantly more likely to use relationship-building techniques, including sharing emotions, expressing a wide variety of emotions, and using positive emotions like smiling and reassurance.

Women experienced physical signs of stress significantly more often. They were also more likely than men to rely on social support from friends and family and to seek professional help to deal with these issues. Women also said that they felt pressure to see more patients in less time and complained about administrative decisions from superiors that added to job stress.

Men said they felt a loss of control because of numerous protocols that must be followed and expressed frustration at not being adequately recognized for their skills.

Both men and women said their jobs frequently interfered with their personal lives and health.

I’d love to hear your thoughts. I love this job yet do believe the more emotionally invested you are, the more stress, pain and anxiety you will experience with your patients. I find it well worth it.

Dr O.

       Send to a Friend     Share This

MORE ARTICLES
CATEGORIES: Personal Opinion
CONDITIONS AND COMMUNITIES: Bladder Cancer  •  Body Modification  •  Bone Cancer  •  Breast Cancer  •  CADASIL  •  Carcinoid Syndrome  •  Career Changes  •  Caregivers  •  Caring For Aging Parents  •  Carpal Tunnel Syndrome  •  Cataracts  •  Cervical Cancer  •  Cocaine Addiction & Recovery  •  Colon Cancer  •  DailyStrength Members Community  •  Esophageal Cancer  •  Eye Cancers (Retinoblastomas)  •  Family & Friends of Cancer Patients  •  Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva  •  Foster Care  •  Gastric Cancer  •  Head and Neck cancers  •  Health Care Reform  •  Health Insurance  •  Hyperammonemia  •  Kids With Cancer  •  Liver Cancer  •  Lung Cancer  •  Male Breast Cancer  •  Medicaid  •  Medical Mysteries  •  Medical Research and Clinical Trials  •  Medicare  •  Military Families  •  Miscarriage  •  Ovarian Cancer  •  Pancreatic Cancer  •  Physical & Emotional Abuse  •  Post Partum Depression  •  Primary Carnitine Deficiency  •  Prostate Cancer  •  Renal Cell Carcinoma (Kidney Cancer)  •  Sciatica  •  Shwachman-Diamond syndrome (SDS)  •  Skin Cancer  •  Step Families  •  Teens With Cancer  •  Testicular Cancer  •  Thyroid Cancer  •  Uterine Cancer  •  Vaginal Cancer  •  Velocardio-facial syndrome  •  Video Game Addiction  •  Vulvar Cancer  •  Williams Syndrome
TAGS:

MEMBER COMMENTS
TOTAL COMMENTS: 3 - View All Comments »

Add a Comment
Displaying comments 3-1 of 3
3
It is certainly better to spend more time with a patient. The problem is the reimbursement is likely to be the same, and thus the added time is not compensated. Using the numbers above, the male doctor might see 10 more patients per week at 100 per patient leads to about 50,000 in added income using round numbers.

I think for the patient it makes sense to see a doctor who is caring and listens. That said, note you cannot necessarily correlate that with diagnostic skill. There are caring doctors who miss things, and nasty arrogant doctors who are nonetheless excellent diagnosticians and may be arrogant because they understand their own abilities.
By Bobby5000  Sep 20, 2010
2
I have had both types of doctors. I do like the connection I get with a woman better, but they are definitely more emotional and not always in a good way. My current doctor is female and although more in tune with my issues and understands how a woman feels (she has found problems male doctors have not) she is often stressed and moody and shows it in her visits. It's a balance of pros and cons... she is good at her job, but when she stresses me out with her stress, it is not good for my health or for me actually wanting to go see her when I am sick.
By butterfliqueen  Jul 09, 2010
1
In my experience with male and female physicians, I would have to say that a definite differences exists. Females are more open and respond to questions in a different way. Whereas a male might say, "I'll have to look at that," most female doctors would say "I'm not sure so let's find the answer." I have excellent physicians (both sexes). I've also had poor physicians (90% male). However, most of the female physicians I know do appear to be over-worked and under great stress. I believe it is the female's natural nurting instinct that causes most of the stress. Women like to "fix" things and have a difficult time accepting that not every patient can be provided exceptional care because there are not enough hours in the day. Just my opinion.
By angieb3511  Jul 08, 2010
Got a Question?
 
 
 
 
My Fans
RELATED SUPPORT GROUPS
Bladder Cancer
(79 Discussion Topics)
Body Modification
(139 Discussion Topics)
Bone Cancer
(64 Discussion Topics)
Breast Cancer
(1,268 Discussion Topics)
CADASIL
(19 Discussion Topics)
Carcinoid Syndrome
(50 Discussion Topics)
Career Changes
(453 Discussion Topics)
Caregivers
(2,004 Discussion Topics)
Caring For Aging Parents
(1,305 Discussion Topics)
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
(262 Discussion Topics)
Cataracts
(100 Discussion Topics)
Cervical Cancer
(412 Discussion Topics)
Cocaine Addiction & Recovery
(1,342 Discussion Topics)
Colon Cancer
(1,463 Discussion Topics)
DailyStrength Members Community
(2,561 Discussion Topics)
Esophageal Cancer
(717 Discussion Topics)
Eye Cancers (Retinoblastomas)
(9 Discussion Topics)
Family & Friends of Cancer Patients
(609 Discussion Topics)
Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva
(3 Discussion Topics)
Foster Care
(375 Discussion Topics)
Gastric Cancer
(60 Discussion Topics)
Head and Neck cancers
(94 Discussion Topics)
Health Care Reform
(245 Discussion Topics)
Health Insurance
(20 Discussion Topics)
Hyperammonemia
(1 Discussion Topics)
Kids With Cancer
(7 Discussion Topics)
Liver Cancer
(193 Discussion Topics)
Lung Cancer
(518 Discussion Topics)
Male Breast Cancer
(3 Discussion Topics)
Medicaid
(57 Discussion Topics)
Medical Mysteries
(163 Discussion Topics)
Medical Research and Clinical Trials
(136 Discussion Topics)
Medicare
(74 Discussion Topics)
Military Families
(1,326 Discussion Topics)
Miscarriage
(10,860 Discussion Topics)
Ovarian Cancer
(787 Discussion Topics)
Pancreatic Cancer
(321 Discussion Topics)
Physical & Emotional Abuse
(22,591 Discussion Topics)
Post Partum Depression
(410 Discussion Topics)
Primary Carnitine Deficiency
(27 Discussion Topics)
Prostate Cancer
(168 Discussion Topics)
Renal Cell Carcinoma (Kidney Cancer)
(587 Discussion Topics)
Sciatica
(455 Discussion Topics)
Shwachman-Diamond syndrome (SDS)
(1 Discussion Topics)
Skin Cancer
(560 Discussion Topics)
Step Families
(1,593 Discussion Topics)
Teens With Cancer
(54 Discussion Topics)
Testicular Cancer
(52 Discussion Topics)
Thyroid Cancer
(768 Discussion Topics)
Uterine Cancer
(164 Discussion Topics)
Vaginal Cancer
(18 Discussion Topics)
Velocardio-facial syndrome
(3 Discussion Topics)
Video Game Addiction
(246 Discussion Topics)
Vulvar Cancer
(130 Discussion Topics)
Williams Syndrome
(48 Discussion Topics)