Discussion Topic

Child Porn Laws to Harsh HELP

Posted on 07/24/11, 02:25 pm
Let me start by giving a brief history: my husband has had issues with pornography for over 20 years. Two years ago he was arrested for downloading and sharing child porn. It took several months for me to sit down and talk with him about this because I could not understand. After speaking with him he explained to me how it happened. He was on limewire just downloading porn, with the legal porn came about 10 videos of what was consider child porn (after the investigation, only 1 of the 10 were actually child porn), he also explain he never intending on sharing the porn, but when the limewire program was set up by my nephew 10 years ago apparently he clicked a button that said share. As a result of all of this our life has been changed forever. My husband lost his job as an operation manager in a large corporation and for the first time in our life we were heading down the public assistance road. Since we did not have a vast knowledge of how the legal system works we listened to what our attorney said to us thinking he had our best interest at heart. We now know that was not the case and more times than not it felt like he was working for the DA, not for us. I just don’t understand how a 1 min and 42 second video that he did not mean to down loaded can change your life, but worse than that how it is that he has to register as a sex offender we he never meant to do this or actually touched a child. I want to work on having these laws changed and I do not have the slightest idea how to do this.So many people’s lives are being devastated because of this and I feel the punishment out ways the crimes. Someone can harm a child and end up with less time then what has happened to my husband. Any adivce anyone can give me I would be greatful. Thank you!
Showing 1 - 10 of 21 Replies
  • Reply #1 07/24/11  2:42pm
    MMy dad is in the exact same predicament. All child porn is a sting by the FBI. My dad has people who have used his computer n it is possible for anyones computer, firewalled and all, to be hacked in. My dad hasn't gone to trial yet, but a man doesn't startbout in his old age liking child porn. I will have to check to see if he had limewire. Thanks for the post. We are devastated.
  • Reply #2 07/24/11  3:16pm
    Make sure he has a good attorney that has a back ground with this, we were told to take the plea or he would go to jail, we were terrfied and we did! His was also caught up in a sting with 10 other people and it did not matter if you had one video or thousands everyone got the same deal. Good look with his case and i will pray for you and your family as you go through this.
  • Reply #3 07/24/11  3:22pm
    I could say so much about this subject (my son is serving 20 years for a shareware program) but honestly it just hurts too much and I don't wanna cry today.
    There is a group in New York who are working to try and fight the CP laws: http://cautionclick.webs.com/
    You might start there by joining the fight for an end to these insane and way too harsh laws. There are alot of really useful links on this page and off the link pages that are helpful.
    If I can be any help, feel free to contact me.
  • Reply #4 07/24/11  3:52pm
    Laurie: Thank you so much for the information, I will check out the website. I have two young sons and want there dad to be able to do things when they have grandkids and in PA he has no restrictions, but we have family all over the midwest and we will never be able to move back there because of this, something needs to change with these laws, I have done a ton of research on why men do this and the bulk of them never have or intended to harm a child, how is it I know this but the law makers wont take the time to do this and would rather ruin peoples lives. It is a witch hunt, I never thought this could happen to us over a video, and now I know the legal system is not just!!!
  • Reply #5 07/24/11  4:12pm
    Anything you find by Troy Stabenow is very informative and helpful. He has an entire report that is full of data. Here is a link to just one article that qoutes him and some of the stats.

    The laws are so unfair. My son never touched anyone, nor would he have, yet his life was taken and our family's life was destroyed. I will fight until I don't have a single breath left in me to change these laws.
    I wish you the very best of luck in your case. I am always here if you need anything.
  • Reply #6 07/24/11  4:15pm
    Christa, I also can relate to your predicament. My BF was on the internet looking at child porn in Dec 2009 and our life as we know it will never be the same again. At the time he was an alcoholic who had addictive tendencies that since have been under control. I guess we can attribute his sobriety to this nightmare. He was lucky to receive 5 years probation and thousands and thousands of dollars (like in the 20k) range in sex offender classes, fines, probation costs, and of course the good ol' ankle monitoring. He was already out of work and it seems even more difficult to even have someone even CONSIDER an application from someone with a felony- especially as a SO. We feel like our lives are forever destroyed. It is difficult and like you, I would like to speak out to the public on this scarlet letter and the complications that lie ahead with moving on. If you figure out how we can be the voices for the SO's out there I would be a part of it. Most of all, I just want my BF to not give up because the system is designed to suppress, suppress---- knock you down. It is not designed to help you.... Good Luck and keep your chin up. Hopefully, you have a great family and support network. : )
  • Reply #7 07/24/11  4:37pm
    I can relate to your story. My husband is now serving in a military prison for CP. He intentionally downloaded it from frostwire & limewire though. They were teens & he was only 20. So it's sorta like a romeo+juliet thing. Anyways.. if you find out anything please do let us know. I've been doing all i can to find out ways to help our case. We're young and have 3 babies. The rest of our lives dealing w/ the RSO list and ridicule from people is just way too much for me to handle.
    I hope you find all the help you're seeking. Try writing your state's government. I've gotten several letters from a governor about my fears and feelings about the RSO laws.
  • Reply #8 07/24/11  10:34pm
    Dear everyone who has posted here thus far -- I am a member of the CautionClick group referenced in Laurie's post. I'm thrilled to see it referenced since it is a fairly new group and just adopted that name about 6 months ago. I joined this Daily Strength website just this week, but I lived in upstate NY until 3 weeks ago and have been an attending member of CautionClick for just under a year. Having found these two groups in the last year tells me a lot. When this calamity happened to me and my husband almost 4 years ago, I searched and searched for group support in vain. It took THREE years to find others in my position. I can tell you it was a very lonely period, knowing no one in my shoes. Finding these two groups means people are beginning to come out of hiding, realizing how unjust the system is, and are beginning to be willing to fight it. I certainly am.

    If you are serious about fighting this stuff, the first most important thing we can do is educate ourselves. There is a great deal of anti-SO law that is finally being produced. Stabenow material is one good source. Material by psych Robert Weiss in L.A. is another great resource. His website is: http://www.sexualrecovery.com/. He also has a very good video for spouses of sex addicts at http://www.vimeo.com/10241385. I HIGHLY recommend: "Justice Perverted" by Charles Patrick Ewing, an attorney and forensic psychologist out of SUNY, Buffalo. His book just came out this year so the only way to get it is to pay full price, but very worth it. Lastly I suggest looking up Nevada therapist Steven Ing on YouTube. He has excellent and hopeful short videos about sex offenders and treatment and public policy.

    The 2nd most important thing we can do, after educating ourselves, is to be a part of one of these grassroots coalitions, like CautionClick. WE MUST ORGANIZE. I am writing a White Paper this summer for CautionClick and the other RSOL groups I belong to (Oklahoma and Ohio) for presentation to legislators, the judiciary, etc. The premise of this paper will be that non-contact, cp cases should be handled differently from contact cases. I want to see the laws and registry changed for everyone, of course. Cases such as Romeo and Juliet, and like Iwantmydad also must be changed, but a white paper should be streamlined, and cp is a place to start. Plus, my own life changed because of underage porn and I find it wholly irrational that possession of images, and the wide range of what is available, is prosecuted more harshly than contact crimes. And there is no proof that cp necessarily constitutes having predatory desires and will result in contact. In England and Wales a first time offense, with no previous criminal history, results in a severe warning and counseling. THAT makes sense.

    A little about me - My husband's cp material was teenage nudity. No sex acts, no males, no adults and no prepubescents involved - just nudity of teens. Plus his participation was very very brief, ending a full year before the police showed up at our door. It is insane that he would have to suffer the same consequences as producers of child porn of little children. While he awaited sentencing he used his marketing skills to create a dynamite public service announcement campaign to warn men not to mess with this stuff. (We found that most people have NO idea the severity of the penalties until they are caught up in this.) Plus, It is unconscionable for the govt to administer such harsh penalties, expecting them to be a deterrent, yet there is NO program warning people and NO ONE KNOWS!

    I have TONS, and I do mean TONS, of research and you are welcome to everything I have. If you email me I can send you a 7 page list of abstracts of about 10 different papers by psychs and attorneys decrying these laws. You can write me at Claire5353.a@aol.com.
  • Reply #9 07/24/11  10:41pm
    I forgot to add that the campaign is a complete package called "Is It Worth It?" Instead of focusing on the wounded children or the moral outrage, the PSA ads are targeted at the men who access this stuff and telling them what they will lose if they even so much as dabble. Robert Weiss endorsed it. But it takes money and LOTS of time to get the necessary endorsements and get it into the hands of the right people. I even took the program to the Rochester, NY office of the NCMEC and they loved it. They thought it could really curb the market for cp. The director told me he would put it before Ernie Allen and get back to me. I never heard from him again. Can you imagine? You give a PREVENTION program on a silver platter to an organization dedicated to saving children in general, and saving kids from child porn in particular. You'd think they would leap at it. Methinks they are more interested knocking off men in possession of it, one at a time, rather than doing some damn prevention.
  • Reply #10 07/24/11  10:44pm
    I have very often seen limewire listed on here when ever someone is talking about cp. I am not sure exactly what kind of site they are but if this is where so much of it comes from ..why arn't they shut down


Join This Group

This group is here to help those with loved ones who are convicted of sex offenses. This is a place where we don't judge because we are all in the same boat, regardless of the actual crime. If you don't feel completely comfortable posting freely on the main board because of the nature of your loved one's crime, feel free to post here because we all understand!