Pediatrician
Dr Shapiro completed his undergraduate education at UC San Diego earning a B S in Biochemistry and Cell Biology and a B A in Political Science He furthered his education at UCLA where he earned a Masters Degree in Public…
FAST FACTS
Bullying: A Needless Event
Posted in ADHD / ADD by Dr. Jeremy F. Shapiro on Oct 26, 2008

I seem to be following a pattern I'd like to avoid...one of commenting on some of the more distressing issues surrounding around children.  And although I will make a conscious effort in the future to emphasize some of the more uplifting stories, I feel obligated to shed light on another heartbreaking situation that occurred not too far from where my children currently attend school.  It is a universal and timeless story about bullying; something I am confident in saying we've all been a part of in our lifetime, whether it be as the bully, the one being bullied, or the bystander.  And it is one where the outcome sadly leads to a life unfairly and cruelly being taken at too young an age.


This tragedy involves a 14-year-old male who had been the target of taunts and criticisms throughout his life time and ultimately reached a point where he finally surrendered to the pain he had endured over the years.  Why he was bullied does not matter...we all know it evolved from someone believing he did not fit in...whether it be something about his physical appearance or a learning deficit or just a unique personality characteristic.  And bringing more agony to any bullying situation is the bully usually commits these actions secondary to his/her own insecurities and an aspiration of just trying to fit in.  But what I ultimately want to draw attention to is what we can do to prevent the unfortunate and unnecessary death of a child who becomes too overwhelmed with the taunts and abuse from his peer. 


So with acknowledgement and thanks to a well used child-rearing book, Caring for Your School-Age Child: Ages 5 to 12, I share with you some very good reminders as to what we, as parents, can do to help our children in bullying situations:



  • It's best to have your child not respond to the bully...something the bully usually feeds on. Try and get your child to just walk away which I realize may not be an easy thing to do.

  • However, if this first measure doesn't work, have your child perform an about-face and be verbally strong with the bully. Things which can be said include, "Stop doing that now. If you keep doing this, I'm going to report you to the principal." Or, "I'll talk to you, but I'm not going to fight. So put your fists down now." This may often calm the situation and even bring other individuals over, which can sometimes embarrass the bully. And don't be afraid to practice this situation with your child at home.

  • The more friends and by this, I mean, strong relationships, the better. The bully...the predator...prefers attacking the isolated and not those in groups.

  • Make sure to talk to your child's teacher and/or principal if things don't resolve. You might think it best not to intervene but if the bullying persists for an extended period of time, as I've noted above, the consequences may be dire.


So with my thoughts to those affected both directly and indirectly in any bullying situation, I leave you with a link to the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) website on Violence Prevention... http://www.aap.org/healthtopics/violprev.cfm.


 


Dr. Jeremy



Displaying comments 31-12 of 31
31
Daughter was bullied in elementary school and in jr high.I have head some people say that they should learn to put up with it because that what happens in the real world and they should except it. As a adult I could and would call the police if someone was bulling me . But the kids are told to deal with it.
By kly  Nov 21, 2008
30
Wow I agree these school systems by us here in Wisconsin are tough. I see more police officers bringing people back to school, or picking them up and taking them away. I always teach my kids to be better than those, and it is difficult but don't react to that negative behavior. I had my daughter come home and tell me 2 parents were in a fight over their daughters. They were taken away and hand cuffed. It is hard with all this peer pressure, and having girls the drama, and bullying is vicious!!!! When i went to school we had hall monitors but now you have the hall moniters and police all over. It is so scary. Thank you for sharing, i always love self-help education. Lord I need it I have a special needs daughter who is bi-polar, post-traumatice stress disorder chronic, odd and adhd. Its been 12 hard years and she has bullied and been bullied. I have 12 years of therapy, hospital programs, self-help books, special education and she is getting better. It is a hard complex child but god gave her to me I am her only lifeline and I keep trudging along.
By kweeks2006  Nov 12, 2008
29
Simply say to the bully, "Forgive me if I hurt your feelings, that was not my intentions."
By WJGonza  Nov 10, 2008
28
Simply say to the bully, "Forgive me if I hurt your feelings, that was not my intentions."
By WJGonza  Nov 10, 2008
27
Simply say to the bully, "Forgive me if I hurt your feelings, that was not my intentions."
By WJGonza  Nov 10, 2008
26
Socrates asserted that the highest good for any human being is happiness. Whatever action a man chooses is motivated by his desire for happiness. Knowledge, virtue, and wisdom are all the same, since man chooses an action according to what he thinks will bring him the greatest happiness. Therefore the more a man knows, the greater his ability to reason out the correct choice and to choose those actions which truly bring happiness to him.
WJGonza
By WJGonza  Nov 10, 2008
25
I was bullied too, from grade 1 to 7. I had those exact same plans on how to stop it, such as talking to him or getting my parents involved. Even suicide sounded good at that point. Nothing worked and he kept doing it. He never got my physically but emotionally and mentally. My friends didn't even stay by me. He turned them all against me just by spreading rumors. Everyone believed him. All I could do was sit there and take everything he threw at me. If this lasted one more year, I just know I would have killed him. I just wish someone would have stuck up for me. Just wish I was stronger. Bullying doesn't have to be about not fitting in. Some bullies just pick on you for no reason at all. I'm sorry if this is too negative but it's what happened to me. I had nobody there for me.
By CloudStrife  Nov 09, 2008
24
Hey Dr Jeremy.....Care to respond to any of this?
By ALC67  Nov 03, 2008
23
I was bullied throuhout middle school. In seventh grade, 5 eighth grade girls jumped me on my way to school. They beat me until I had blood running down my face. I stumbled home; my mom called the police who came and took down a report. All the girls had previous records but one was the principal's granddaughter and I don't think any of them ever received any punishment. I am 49 years old, have been in and out of therapy all my life (for a variety of reasons, adult child of alcoholic, major depressive disorder, etc). I take meds and try to work my mental health program, but there is not a day that goes by that I don't think about that day. I don't want to think about it but it lives in my mind as a defining moment in my life. On the occasions when I've been suicidal, that incident is right in the forefront of my mind. I would like closure on it but it may never happen. I'm sitting here crying right now as I remember it. So, yeah, I'd say bullying is a major problem.
By oooooo  Nov 01, 2008
22
I was also bullied in school,we were military and moved around alot.
I had a strong southern accent when we moved to virginia..got picked on nonstop for that...I hated living in Richmond..kids were extremely mean there. Woodbridge was a little better...I was in middle school there developed early,girl who live around the corner from me was on meds and they made her irratable..she took it out on me.....found her a few years ago on classmates.com and told her off....it felt great, she even apologized wrote me a long email saying how sorry she was...amazing!
High school was in Florida.....everyone was in preppy phase here "early eighties".;....I just didn't fit in hence the harraassment started up again.....I just kept my head down , got my license early drove myself to school ...took some fluff college coures so that when I graduated high school I would not be starting out behind in college..actually college was great because I already had a group established and realy fit in well there......
By michaux42  Oct 31, 2008
21
I was always bullied on the school bus. No place to walk away. I was always sitting RIGHT BEHIND THE DRIVER, and she did NOTHING to stop them. I eventually would make sure I had a book with me (I have always loved to read) and then when the bulliers started making their mean comments and annoying noises at me, I'd just whip out my book, read, and ignore them. I could still hear them, but the book kept my attention enough that I didn't feel like I had to respond to them. They never did anything worse than verbally bullying me, but that was bad enough. After second grade I was pulled out and homeschooled and then earned my GED before going to college.
By estrellaSMC  Oct 29, 2008
20
Wish that advice had been around when I was a kid. I was severely bullied throughout my school years, most severely in elementary school and NO ONE WOULD HELP ME! I complained to my mom and she's give me pithy sayings like 'Rise above it.' That means a lot to a 7 year old. She went to the school and the principal and teahcer just told her 'Boys will be boys' and 'She has to learn to take care of herself.' I was raised to NOT fight, so how was I supposed to 'take care of myself'?
I begged my mom to take me out of school and home school me or get me a tutor or something like that so I wouldn't have to face the pain every day but she said it was important for my 'socialization' to go to school. As a result I went through years of unadulterated hell. I was stalked (i had to walk home a different way every day in case someone was waiting to ambush me...sometimes I guessed wrong), I was pushed into the street in front of moving cars, I was pushed down and spit on, had soda spit on me, gum stuck in my hair, in winter it was ICE balls (not snow balls) often with rocks inside. My lockers were broken into, my things stolen, my papers ruined and you can imagine what kind of education I got. If I told my father about any of this he'd call the police, who wouldn't do anything either.
In high school it got more serious with gang beatings (one troubled girl told her friends I'd said something about her mother...which I didn't....she and all her friends cornered me in the hallway to 'teach me a lesson'). You think weapons in school is something new? Hah. I had a knife pulled on me in front of the library back in '79. No one did anything. As usual.
And people wonder why I am the way I am now.
By ALC67  Oct 28, 2008
19
Hey everybody!
I'm new to this support group (& I can't spel good LOL!).
By sheer coincidence, I just happen to be an expert on bully management. At least, I think I am, though I am biassed.
I have been a martial arts instructor for almost 20 years and bully management has been a focal point of my classes. I am aware that this is a very touchy subject and opinions run very strong, so I want to be clear that what I am commenting is simply one guy's opinion.

Jeremy, I applaud the empathy that I hear in your comments. This is paramount.

I respectfully disagree that the bullying takes place because of anything that has to do with the person being bullied. A bully bullies because of themselves and not because of anything about the person being bullied. Clarity on this is very important when talking to our youngsters.

There is a formal definition of bullying. It is when someone uses some sort of power to cause another person to feel intimidated.

In my state, once in 7th grade, bullying is referred to as harrassment.

It is an error to say that any certain action is a best response to a bully because the gratification that a particular bully is receiving is the key to inturrupting the pattern. For example, most bullies pick on the easiest target, correction, they pick on WHAT LOOKS LIKE THE EASIEST TARGET, such that the best remedy is to not look like the easiest target. Body language, tone of voice, facial experessions (smile v. frown), isolated or with interacting with others, all these play a part in the message to the bully about how easy of a target the person is.

The reason a single suggested response is not good is because not all bullies pick on the easiest target. Some look for trophies, aka social stepping stones that the bully feels threatened by and some bullies get gratification out of making someone cry or lose their cool and blow up and put on a show. To effetively negate the gratification that the bully is internalizing, the potential victim must first identify the sourse of the gratification of the bully. This can be attained by watchig the bullies facial expressions in response to various stimuli.

Intervening is very risky. Plan A should definitely be to function as the potential victim's coach. If you can successfully coach the potential victim through the situation, then you accomplish a lot of tremendous things. You metaphorically teach the individual to fish rather than giving them fish, their self-confidence will grow from knowing that they stood up to the bully and you navigate away from the fist steps of a co-dependant song and dance that nets the result of you fighting their battles and then when you are not there, they fall harder than they would have in the first place had you not intervened. This does not mean that there is not a time to intervene, it just means that before you intervene, you should think real hard about it.

There are several exercises that a person can do with a young person, or adult for that matter. My favorite one is one on translation. The exercise is designed to educate the potential victim. The more educated the potential victim is about the dynamics of bullying, the more empowered thay are to peacable attain resolve with their bully and then use those same life skills later in their lives when the situation is simply an adult version of bullying at work at a social event.

Here's some examples of how to educate the potential victim:

(I call this the "translating lesson")

When a bully says: I hate you! You are too tall! You are too dumb! I'm going to hit you! You! You! You!

An accurate translation of what the bully is saying is: "I got problems with myself! I wishy I was taller! Other peoople picked on me saying that I was dumb! My problems are Me! Me! Me!

If the potential victim can learn to see this, then their whole perspective changes. Their self-worth becomes protected because they begin to understand that what the bully says has nothing to do with them and has everything to do with the bully. With understanding, fear typically begins to deminish and the potential victim is, for the first time, able to navigate through the situation aided by their new-found clarity of what has actually been going on since day one.

I think I'm starting to lecture. Sorry. Like I said before, just one guys opinion.

Good - luck!
By friendxyz  Oct 27, 2008
18
Even though I'm an adult, I'm still haunted by the bullying I suffered throughout my school years. There was no help from parents and teachers and I don't think it's much better today. There is no accountability but how to change it? Have adults monitoring the halls and schoolyard before and after school when kids are most vulnerable? I recently read "Odd Girl Out" a book that addresses the bullying that goes on between girls. "Please Stop Laughing at Me" by Jodee Blanco was also a good read but the ending is an exception and not the rule. It's inspiring to see her come full circle and face her tormentors years later at a high school reunion but not very realistic. I wish we all could have been taken on a trip to Greece by our parents when we were enduring the worst in high school. Still, I'm glad her story turned out so well.
I had a hard time reading the first book "Odd Girl Out" because I'd been in denial for so long about all the bullying I'd endured in school. I got in touch with alot of anger and pain which was difficult but also a relief. I didn't have to pretend to myself anymore that what happened to me was no big deal, that it was okay when in reality it was not!
The way I finally found a way to stop it is certainly not recommended in any books I'd venture a guess. I finally fought back against a guy - a jock - that was picking on me one day. He was getting physical and I had to punch him out. He was so shocked he didn't know what to do. Never expected one of his victims - girls and little kids - to acually fight back. He did pretty much leave me alone after that. It was a pivotal event for me. I'd been abused in so many other ways, too and it was the first time I'd had the strength to fight back. It helped me to see that I didn't have to put up with that kind of abuse. And it helped me believe that I deserved better, that I could have better.
Too bad bullying still goes on with adults in the work place......
By StillSearching  Oct 27, 2008
17
My opinion is that bullying is totally wrong. It's the beginning to what will probably end of with no good. It's really senseless and if someone needs to bully someone just to act like he is superior, I pray for him/her, because at the end of the day this person has mental problems. To not care for someone that is different or just for the hell of it it's just totally stupid and ignorant. Those were great advices by Jeremy F. Shapiro, MD. as for a comment by girl199017 I think you are in a lot of pain, because since you say you have a lot of exerpeience in this kinda of means that you are still taunted by your past. Let it go...remember you are special and nobody should have to go through this, especially kids. Look what happened in Columbine HS. They just couldn't bare it anymore and their time bomb just went off. Everyone, I think has a limit, but the advice that Jeremy Shapiro, MD gave is something that should be used. You have a voice and how cares if they laugh at you, it's about doing something and not going down to the bullies level. I pray that some day, we will all get together, because this is our world & everyone has the same right to be safe, happy, enjoyment, fulfillment in their lives here. Peace-out!
-riverlost
By riverlost  Oct 27, 2008
16
I am indeed going to go and read the article. My son has Aspbergers syndrome and so at the age off 11 still has not one friend.
Last year he cried each and every day about bullies. I did call the school on several occasions. Either bullies are getting meaner since I was his age, or I just "fit in" better and did not suffer what he goes thru! :(
By KatieJP  Oct 27, 2008
15
while i do recognise and respect the support and advice you are giving, i have to say that it sounds like you don't have any experience on the subject yourself, and therefore are not the best person to be giving advice on bullying. your advice on what to do in 'bullying situations' is not helpful. if they bully is very violent, and if the victim said - "Stop doing that now. If you keep doing this, I'm going to report you to the principal", the victim would probably get laughed at or kicked in. and your suggested "I'll talk to you, but I'm not going to fight. So put your fists down now", is just plain ridiculous. the bullies i had laughed when i said things like that and humiliated me even more. as well as this, victims often have NO self-esteem because of the bullying, and therefore will NOT BE ABLE to say such a confident, in-control thing like this. ALSO, you say 'keep your fists down' which is very very ignorant as bullying ofen is VERBAL AND EMOTIONAL rather than physical. and as for your advice - "The more friends and by this, I mean, strong relationships, the better" - GET REAL. bullies often set many others against the victim(s) which means it will be VERY DIFFICULT for the victim to make or keep friends. other children often are too scared to be friends with victims of bullying because of the fear that they will also become targets.

I AM SPEAKING FROM LOTS OF PERSONAL EXPERIENCE.

PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ADVICE LIKE THIS WHEN YOU CLEARLY DONT KNOW WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT

JUST BECAUSE YOU WERE SMART AND DID WELL AT SCHOOL DOES NOT MEAN YOU KNOW BEST
By girl199017  Oct 27, 2008
14
I was bullied as a child because I was far more intelligent than the Popular Girls and uninterested in dresses, make-up and boys (but instead in cars, hockey and creative writing). Your suggestions of passive finger-wagging did absolutely no good back then, even against girls. What finally stopped the bullying was that I turned on the girl who was the leader and beat the daylights out of her. (For the time -- several good solid blows, as I recall.) While I was sent to counseling to find out why I was not more Ladylike -- which I handled by not speaking to the counselor at all, something I have been able to do easily as my parents believed in Seen and Not Heard -- I was not bullied again by anyone in that crowd. Threatening to tattle is a deadly suggestion. Nobody likes a rat fink.
By Appleby  Oct 27, 2008
13
I never bullied anyone but I did stand by while my friends teased a learning disabled girl in grade school; I then felt guilt and told my friends to stop. I wanted to say something (kind) to the victim but never had the nerve. What I was witness to was a result of peer pressure. I myself was bullied in violent ways as a teen. I was attacked and beaten by many other girls. I wonder to this day, if my daily headaches are a result of the violence. I never told anyone, let alone an adult.
If I was a teen today, when the beatings occured, it would likely end up on the internet, as I see so many kids these days doing similar things, and videotaping it to display for the world to see. I've even heard the goal of that is to see which videos get the most "views". Clearly, the internet has only worsened bullies' ability to torment their victims. They go online and make up lies and insults so their peers can see.
To a child or teen, this is the worst thing in their world that could possibly happen. Often they are driven to desperate means to escape, including suicide or homicide. I feel that all schools, teachers and parents should teach the children from an early age, about tolerance and respect of others, of respect for those who may be "different", and respect for human life itself. I feel the things they are doing these days shows a complete lack of respect or caring for people or lives.
It should be taught in an age appropriate way, from first grade on...and every year, it should be re-addressed to keep it fresh in their minds. I feel teachers should have extra training to detect signs of bullies, and how to deal with it,as well as teaching respect as part of the curriculum.
Clearly, this affects us into adulthood. I see adults on the internet lately, bullying each other, too.
I went through the situation when my son was in school, too. I always told him that the people picking on him had problems and maybe someone picked on them at home and they felt bad about themselves and that's why they picked on him.
But most importantly, we kept an ongoing dialogue with each other, on what responses he might use, and we did role playing scenerios....I suggested to him that his sense of humor could be a good shield, which turned out to work for him.. But we practiced at home until he felt confident..
By ThisToo  Oct 27, 2008
12
I read what I had just typed and realized that the bullying didn't stop until the END OF 10TH GRADE when we moved away and started another in another district, I still feel that most people don't like me because of that fact. I have social anxiety disorder, my anxiety level goes way up when there is a large amount of people in a room. I actually hid behind a coatrack at a church because I didn't know anyone in the room.

StephP
By StephP  Oct 27, 2008

PAGE:  < Previous  |  1  |   2  |   Next >
Got a Question?
 
 
 
 
My Fans