Marriage and Family Therapist
Cyndi Sarnoff-Ross is a licensed psychotherapist with almost twenty years of clinical experience in the fields of clinical psychology and organizational management br br She has worked extensively with a wide variety of…
Pink or Blue – What’s it to you?
Posted in Single Parentin... by Cyndi Sarnoff-Ross on May 04, 2009

Amy Wilson from Parenting.com wrote a funny and poignant article about why she "didn't want a girl." The gender of a child is a hot topic for expecting parents and people deal with this issue in many different ways. Amy Wilson's candor about her feelings was refreshing and many people cannot articulate why it is that they would prefer a child of one gender over the other.

From the moment a couple gets the news of a pregnancy the notion of pink or blue enters the room. Rightfully, the primary concern of any expectant parent is and should be the health of the baby. But the gender of an unborn baby can occupy to-be parent's thoughts. Some couples are eager to find out the gender and others want it to remain a surprise until birth. Personally this has always puzzled me because in both of my pregnancies finding out the gender made me feel more connected to the baby and I felt as if that information took the bonding process to a new level. I recognize that this is my own personal feeling and one that is very subjective.

I have heard many good reasons for not wanting to know the gender of an unborn baby as well. For instance, some women, particularly those who have had repeated miscarriages, would prefer not to feel as bonded to a child until they were actually holding their baby. This makes a great deal of emotional sense. One woman I know who had a boy was hoping for a girl the 2nd time around and found out the gender in utero, which led to some depression for the remainder of the pregnancy. When baby #2 was born she adored him instantly and any thought of gender became irrelevant. For baby #3 she chose to wait until the birth so those love hormones would take over - and they did. She had a 3rd boy and couldn't be happier to be the mom in a household full of testosterone. And then there is the ever present reason for wanting the gender to be a surprise with the often repeated mantra of, "there are so few surprises in life I want this to be one of them." Well anyone who is a parent can tell you that once that baby is born your life will be overflowing with surprises.

Whether or not you want to know the gender of your unborn child is less important than understanding your own preconceived notions about gender and your ability to relate to one gender over another. These notions are all born out of your own personal experience and often a result of your relationship with your own parents. As Amy Wilson so aptly points out, people make assumptions about other's desires as well. When a pregnant woman announces that she has 2 boys people automatically assume they are trying for a girl. Sometimes I hear parents of 2 children, one of each gender, say, "we have our boy and our girl so we are done having kids "- as if that was the goal. People come from very different perspectives on this issue and sometimes those perspectives reside within one family. This can be truly challenging.

There is no doubt that males and females are different right from the start and as they grow they present different challenges and different types of joys. (For more information on this read my earlier Blog ). Understanding your own beliefs about what a certain gender of a child will bring to your family and preparing yourself for any outcome can help prevent a feeling of grief if things do not turn out as planned. What are the messages you received about being a boy or a girl - from your parents and from the world? What are your beliefs about the roles the genders play in society and in families? What are your fears or hopes about having a boy or a girl? Have you and your mate discussed these topics and how you will both embrace the eventuality of any outcome?

I am the mother of 2 girls and personally I was thrilled to find out that I was having a second girl. My husband and I liked the idea of sisters and I already knew how to be a girl mom. It is what I know. I suppose I liked the symmetry of it all. Maybe had I had a boy first I would have felt differently - maybe not. Either way as Amy Wilson said in her article, "I love what I have and I have what I love".

 


CATEGORIES: Tips
CONDITIONS AND COMMUNITIES: Single Parenting
TAGS:

Displaying comments 6-1 of 6
6
I was disappointed when my sister's first child ended up being a boy, because I felt that we wouldn't have much in common and that he wouldn't want to spend time with me. He turned out to be my best friend, and we have more in common and get along better than his younger sister and I do. We have a truly special relationship. So I've given up preconceived notions of what "girls are like" and what "boys are like", and I will take each child as he or she comes.
Cyndilu, it breaks my heart that your mother treated you so poorly. I wish that everyone had to struggle to have kids the way I have done... then maybe people wouldn't take them for granted. (you know, if they come easily (or accidentally) sometimes people just take them for granted and treat them poorly)
It used to make me cry to work at the county hospital and talk to those people about their children, and to see how little they cared for their children and how poorly they treated them, when I would have done anything to have a child to treasure but just had a miscarriage. You see serious abuse and neglect cases at the county hospital. It is absolutely astounding to see what people are capable of.
By DrKathy  May 09, 2009
5
It was devastating to me when my poor little shallow mother commented casually: "I was so disappointed when they brought you to me and I saw you were a girl---I just cried and cried." I suppose some people don't have good parenting instincts.
And perhaps that was one reason I never wanted to know what any of my five children was until I met them. I ended up with three boys and two girls...I have to admit that I was slightly apprehensive with the first girl since I'd grown accustomed to those three boys, but they have all been such joys, and just as they should be.
Cyndilu, I am in total empathy with you. I heard remarks like that all my life. I think maybe she just had these illusions about herself based on books she'd read, or movies she'd seen, and she was trying to be profound or something...Really really sad. People like that miss so much. Don't worry about your own dear daughter, she probably would have been high-maintenance anyway and what counts is that she's a great mom and your friend. :)
FLgirl96, I really think that that adult relationship you enjoyed so much with your mom probably had less to do with your gender than with the two of you as individuals. My relationships with my adult children range from "reserved affectionate" to soulmate indpendent of gender and regardless of the fact that I really like all of them and I really do love each as much as the other. Attentions which one child really enjoys may just really annoy another, so you have to find different ways to give attention to each one... I think you either hit it off personality wise or you don't, but as long as love and respect are there, and an honest attempt by each party to be courteous and supportive and truly charitable---that's really the best you can ask for, and sometime you get SO MUCH more. Sons can be incredible friends, and when one brings home a wonderful wife that you really hit it off with, it's like getting a bonus baby.
By romanreb  May 07, 2009
4
My mother made such a fuss over her two boys that she neglected us two girls. Now, her two boys could care less about her as I, the youngest (a girl) have to take care of her in her last years. My sister (a crack addict) that I'm sure became that way because of the way my mom treated us, only shows up when she needs money. I haven't heard anything from my brothers, my mom's two oldest, in years. I (the youngest and most hated by my mom in my youth)am the only one who cares for her daily well-being. But, I do remember all of the bad treatment she gave me coming up. She actually told me that she "loves me because I'm her child but doesn't like me at all" when I was a child. People need to know that they shape the soul and outlook of a child by the way they care for them in their formative years. Luckily, I think that my daughter (an only child) knows that I love her and consider her one of my friends now that she's grown. I also think that I showed her so much love and attention that she's now high maintenance and selfish but still lovable and a wonderful mother to her two boys.
By cyndilu  May 05, 2009
3
I am the father of two daughters and could not be happier. I can honestly say that I did not care as long as they were healthy. I have on the other hand heard some of the stupidest comments imaginable. I had a teacher make the comment "anyone can make girls, it takes a man to make a boy"....his "boy" is a complete waste...I have heard "so are you going to try for a boy?, on the other hand I have heard women make comments..."she had another boy...thats to bad". I love my daughters more than life itself, the relationship between a father and daughter is so special......as is the one between a father and son, mother and daughter, mother and son.......different doesn't mean better,there is nothing in this world I would trade for what I have with my daughters....anyone who thinks they would be happier with a different gendered child....doesn't deserve that child....
By doalan  May 04, 2009
2
The timing of this article and the one from CNN is so ironic. I recently found out I am having a second boy and am struggling with it in spite of how grateful I am he's healthy. I never pictured being a mom without having a daughter and now I face that reality since our family plan was for two children. Your questions in particular have given me food for thought and for discussion with my therapist. One angle that's foremost in my mind that isn't mentioned in either article is the difference in the adult relationships between mothers/daughters vs. mothers/sons. I am blessed with an incredible relationship with my own mother and am mourning the loss of the opportunity to pass that on.
By FLgirl96  May 04, 2009
1
ha ha, we had one boy and seriously wanted and had another. lets just say they were resilient enough to handle my immature parenting methods. they are both now very nice men who had fun childhoods'. i love those f###ers. nice article, bob
By capnhardass  May 04, 2009
Got a Question?
 
 
 
 
My Fans
POPULAR POSTS