Marriage and Family Therapist
Cyndi Sarnoff-Ross is a licensed psychotherapist with almost twenty years of clinical experience in the fields of clinical psychology and organizational management br br She has worked extensively with a wide variety of…
Not Every Problem is Searching for a Solution
Posted in Anxiety by Cyndi Sarnoff-Ross on Sep 14, 2009

There are some people who seem to lead off every interaction with a complaint. You may ask a simple question of them such as, "How are you?" and you are bombarded by a list of woes - on a regular basis. Some people have simply learned to communicate this way and, depending upon your personality (whether or not you tend to be a fixer) you may or may not feel obliged to help them solve their problem in that moment. You may want to keep in mind that complaining doesn't always mean someone wants advice. In fact, many who chronically complain may be annoyed by your offering up solutions or trying to fix the problem.

This article does NOT refer to those who have genuine distress or chronic pain and who share that information with people but instead I am referring here to people who seem to have an easier time forming sentences into complaints than into any other type of expression.  Interacting with this type of person requires both patience and empathy but not always a solution. If the person that comes to mind when you hear this description is a loved one and someone with whom you have regular interactions then you may want to try just being a listener.

Often solving the problem right away (unless it is an obvious and easily solvable problem) takes away the very thing that person was using to connect to you. It can even lead to the expression of more complicated problems. Stop and ask yourself if the person's complaint is one you hear frequently from them or if it is something more acute. Before jumping to the rescue consider letting the person know that you hear them, maybe even reflect back to them what you have just heard, and then try moving on to a new topic.

In couples, complainers and fixers often find their way to each other. In this way everyone has their assigned roles and it can be very hard to dislodge people from those positions. Sometimes the dynamic is case specific. Do you ever notice that you complain more around some people than others? Start to notice if this is the case and why you may feel compelled to do so. Some people bring out the whiner in all of us because they seem so eager to be helpful and it does make most of us feel good to be helpful.

So before you get annoyed with that chronic complainer in your life, ask yourself if there is anything you are doing to encourage the behavior. Try not to be so quick with the solutions but offer instead a sympathetic ear. If you recognize the behavior in yourself, then consider holding back on complaints that don't really require assistance and search for new and better ways to connect with others.


CATEGORIES: Personal Opinion
CONDITIONS AND COMMUNITIES: Anxiety  •  Breakups & Divorce  •  Caregivers  •  Depression  •  Family Issues  •  Healthy Relationships  •  Life After Divorce  •  Stress Management
TAGS:

Displaying comments 41-22 of 41
41
Whether someone is a complainer or just comes to me once and expresses an issue they are dealing with or concerned about, my first instinct is to offer advice and how they alleviate it or look more deeply in to the cause. I never think that some times, I just need to step back, listen and possibly ask opened ended questions in order to keep them feeling like they can continue to express themselves because just as you said, I cut off the very means they have to communicate with me by doing that.

At least I am now more conscious of my own behavior in those situation and am trying to work on it, but I still slip and want to fix it and make it all better.
By ChiTownBear  Oct 25, 2009
40
My answer to that question depends on when it's asked really. Most times I'll say, "doing good, doing good"...and other times I'll say, "well I'm in pretty good shape for the shape I'm in"....or, "I'm doing great spiritually and mentally but the physical sucks"...lol

It's all in the attitude. I'm a chronic pain sufferer. I can't remember ever in my whole life not having pain. But I have a choice to let it cause me to be bitter, angry and miserable to be around, to a happy joyous and free person who loves life and know that all that happens in life is part of God's plan for me.

Not always easy, there are times where I will just put the info out there, such as I'm fixin to do here, just o know and let others know that none of us are alone in this chronic pain stuff.

Hi ya'll, I'm Kat and new here, new to blogging and reading here.

I have MS, Fibro, CFS, Osteoporosis of the left hip and lower spine, osteoarthritis of the spine and hips and joints, 3 buldging disks, IBS, chronic nausea, had a heart attack Nov 17th of 07. And a few other medical issues. Been dealing with doctors all my life and as many of you can relate to it gets old, we won't even go there because I could write a whole book on the medical profession, I'm an RN retired due to all these issues.

See? It would be very easy for me to complain alot. And there are times I catch myself complaing but then I read something like this blog and say yeah, I'm grateful I don't do that alot. It's only on those seemingly impossible days, when you can feel the willingness to go on slipping away, that's the days I complain.

Well sorry for the ramble, I tend to o that now and then

Kat
By Ramblerkat  Oct 05, 2009
39
i'm Always negative and complaing; i hate that about myself as much as i hate uninvited solutions... man i'm a btch! ..see! negative all day all the time... anyone's invited to comment wt/or w/out a solution.
By dzzy  Sep 29, 2009
38
I totally understand what you mean, some friends and family have a bit of a moan whenever I see them but I think they they are just getting it off their chest, they don't actually expect you to help or give solution just want to be heard, as we all know, even to talk about something sometimes helps us as its nice just to be heard, sometimes people like someone to listen to them
By janeyjane  Sep 22, 2009
37
I feel offended, you state that certain ppl are NOT REALLY having hard time. They just complain. So if you state the thing more than once or so u become such a complainer....Or at least u cannot distinguish the real complainer from the non-real. Some ppl experience chronic stress- being single parent who works 2-3 jobs to provide, or person who cares for the sick relative. All tey hear- stop complaining, or I hear you- everything will be fine instead of getting some real help or advice...
By gluzanna  Sep 22, 2009
36
So true! This is advice that can be applied to different scenarios, not just whining. Very insightful... loved it!
By Sofia  Sep 21, 2009
35
This is truly a tricky subject. My own personal experiences have been varied. I tend to be a fixer, myself, so I find myself eager to hear how someone "really" is. But, now, having chronic health issues myself, I find it exhausting to try to help fix others when I can't even figure out how to fix myself, but I still ask. At times, when I hear the outcries of others, it opens me to a new way of thinking about my situation and I often end up Googling possible help for the people, and have had some decent results in a few cases. I think it helps to listen to people, as well as have someone listen to us, because often it's where new information comes from. That person we vent to may have been through what we're going through and know some helpful information to pass on to us, and vice versa. I guess everything in moderation is key, here. It's hard to find the balance between under-involved and over-involved, but we must be mindful of that. All it costs us is a smile and some of our time. We never know when something we say may make a life-altering event come about. Left unsaid, we'd never know. Just a thought.
By RaeDreams  Sep 21, 2009
34
you are still very boring. Chronic complainers are just looking for love. If people stop responding to that behavior they will come up with a better one.
By donna56  Sep 20, 2009
33
I find myself in both of these roles, I am known far and wide for being the fixer! I just once would like someone, a loved one, co-worker or family member, come to me and say "what can I do to make your life a little less stressful today?"NOT THAT I WOULD LET THEM! :-) I have also been told I am not an easy person to do something for. But just recently I realized that these "LIKE" personality come together because of the strange comfort the roles afford each other. What I have been doing is ignoring the complainers to the point where they are asking me "am I just a whiner"? I reply no, I am just a fixer and I can't fix your issue today. For once I realize I am the enabler.......Geez, only 55 years it took me to figure that one out. I do think that as a child of GOD I am my brother keep, but I am certain HE wouldn't want me to do things with an unkind heart.
By shotzy54  Sep 20, 2009
32
good advice indeed. It is hard enough to say what I really want to say, the first time. It takes time... listening to my own voice, with an ear which listens or feels what is being said, to get to the real root of the reason for expressing. Sometimes the words are only messengers of the Spirit which only wants to LIVE and let live. thxs. I hear you. TBS
By tbs1  Sep 20, 2009
31
I totally agree with why do people even bother to ask.
I often hear people ask,
"How are you doing"? and the answer is "How are you doing?"
Everybody seems quick to ask the question, though really don't care about the answer. It's very superficial. I prefer simply saying hello, if, I don't have time or really don't want to know. It's a little more genuine, in my opinion.
By page  Sep 20, 2009
30
Well, it's true that nobody wants to hear a slew of complaints when they ask how you are, but it's also very odd to have such a meaningless social convention where you ask the other person "how are you?" and the only acceptable answer they can give is "fine". Perhaps all cultures have this in some sense. I've heard that in some parts of China they will ask upon greeting, "have you eaten?" and the only acceptable answer is "yes". Anything else is taken as a complaint or even a request to be fed. I think in America it's okay to respond with a short, positive statement such as, "oh, I've been taking up pottery recently and having fun with it". Negatives also have to be short, and restrained to things like the weather, and sometimes even that's tricky, some people get their hackles up if you respond with anything other than "fine" and might say, "well, why don't you move, then?" or something equally dumb. The whole social veneer thing is dumb, but it's fairly unavoidable.
By deanna2150  Sep 19, 2009
29
You have no idea how crazy the timing of my reading this is at this moment.....THANK YOU for writing this...I needed to read this.....I am the epitome of a "fixer" and while I am also a wonderful listener, I tend to try to push an issue someone is having so we can solve it .......I will do my best to stop this behavior...this was a true eye opener for me.
By Kaino  Sep 19, 2009
28
When I read this article it opened my eyes, My Father had had major health problems, when he spoke to people before anything he gave them a full report of his health, and very often after that he had no more to say, I hated it when he did that, my brother also.

Then in 1995 I was injured at the job, I worked for the NYS Dept. of corrections. I had many, many complictions, and soon I found myself doing the same thing. They told my wife I would never survive, well she ended up with Ovarian cancer and I lost her in 2007, here I am and she's gone,, Go figure, I find myself still doing this. When people ask you how are you, they don't want a full report on your problems. when they say How are you, they want to know how you are and that's it, If they want to know more, they will ask again. I try very hard now not to do the wrong thing.

Many people do this, just not me, or one or two more people. It is a habit, and one that needs to be corrected. I did have someone tell me aout it, but I guess i have forgotten, so the artcle Cyndi has wrriteen her is a real eyeopener for me, and maybe many people. Again, if people really want to know what your complaints are they will ask you more than once, then it is a safe play to complain, other than communication should be limited. I know, I have had people walk away,,, maybe run would be a better word. Thanks Cyndi.
By sparks1179  Sep 18, 2009
27
PERFECT! You hit a bulls eye!

I can think of two very important people in my life that I want to share this article with. With one, I'm the "complainer" and they are the "fixer," even when I'm NOT complaining! Many times, I'm just stating a fact of something that I can fix myself or that doesn't need fixing at all, and these statements are read as complaints. But it all started with my very real health problems which really DID need fixing. Ultimately it was me who found the doctor to "fix" it, and it was the doctor who did fix it, but my very special "fixer" loved me all the way through it, even in my darkest days, and helped me tremendously.

With the other, THAT person is the complainer, probably because it is ME who has done so much "fixing" of that particular person's problems, because that person really needed me and I am so glad I was there to do it ALL!

But now my "complainer" (who complains too much), my "fixer" (who is driving me nuts trying fix things that don't need fixing), and me (who is still BOTH "complaining" to my "fixer"; AND attempting to "over-fix" my "complainer") all have to stop this nonsense! We all three need to live more in the moment and enjoy life one day at a time!
By nightbyrd  Sep 18, 2009
26
Just as you smile, I smile! Smiling breaks all kinds of ice. Yea!
By BIGBEARSHEART  Sep 18, 2009
25
Good article and one I can so relate to.My husband was diagnosed with this incurable diease in 1995.and went from Stage 1 to Stage 3 fst.His whole life is focused on his disease..I have given up on asking how he is.? as It oH I am in so much pain.Poor me attitde like he is the only one in the world that ever suffers with pain.....I don't ask any more..
By 4getmenot  Sep 18, 2009
24
Note for Fixers: Often times fixers offer what is an obvious solution without thought that the obvious action has already been considered or taken by the complaintant...or that the complaint is not the actual problem. The complainer may not know what the real problem is, or may not be able to discuss the real problem.
By alyssum  Sep 17, 2009
23
I feel like before someone asks how someone is,they should question whether or not they really want to know....It seems like we ask people out of habit when we say hello and then get annoyed when they respond with their troubles.Maybe the people complaining really need to talk and by posing the question ,we are opening the door???I don't think we should place blame on people complaining.don't ask if you don't want to know
By moonstruckme  Sep 17, 2009
22
I do not make a habit of complaining to others because I do understand that it is not their problem to correct, along with also understanding that it can be painful sharing your pains with others. The good thing though is that I have little to complain about anyway.

What I would like to know is, that as a professional, do you always handle yourself APPROPRIATELY in ALL instances, do you practice what you preach, and how difficult is it for you to do so? I would appreciate it if you could get back to me on this question, but failing to do so will have me believe that you INDEED DO.
By BeatinBP  Sep 17, 2009

PAGE:  < Previous  |  1  |   2  |   3  |   Next >
Got a Question?
 
 
 
 
My Fans
POPULAR POSTS