Marriage and Family Therapist
Cyndi Sarnoff-Ross is a licensed psychotherapist with almost twenty years of clinical experience in the fields of clinical psychology and organizational management br br She has worked extensively with a wide variety of…
Dealing with the “Mean Girl”
Posted in Anxiety Disorde... by Cyndi Sarnoff-Ross on Nov 07, 2008

 



If you are a female and remember your childhood, or you have a daughter older than 4, you know that girls can be tough on themselves and to each other. The mean girl personality seems to be appearing earlier and earlier these days possibly due to media influences or just kids growing up faster. Many women recount painful memories of their childhood and being taunted, bullied or ignored by kids they thought were their friends. Girls have a unique brand of torture they inflict on one another juxtaposed to boys who may duke it out but all is well soon after.


"Mean girl" behavior is not the same as being a leader or strong willed. Those are personality traits which can be positive and fun to be around. If your child has been on the receiving end of a mean girl's vitriol then the difference is clear. The behavior I am discussing here is clearly defined as being hurtful and malicious. It may include telling friends who they can and can't be friends with or talking in a made up language or code that your child doesn't understand. There may be direct insults or criticism that leaves your child feeling badly about them self.


Often the mean behavior is extremely subtle and hard to identify because it comes in the form of exclusion, which is also termed "relational aggression". Young girls form cliques and the "mean girl or girls" dictate who can be a part of the group and who cannot. The other, less dominant members, fear becoming an outsider and will typically go along with the leader's mandates. What is particularly confusing to some children is that this exclusion is not always consistent. One day they may be in and another day they are out. Parents will describe how painful it is to watch their child suffer in this way as they begin to realize that they can't fully protect them from all the evils of the world. But they can arm them with the skills to manage their social world and to ask for help when they need it.


Ask your daughter about her interactions at school and how she feels about them. Start doing this at a very early age so that she gets the idea that you are involved, interested and there to assist if need be. As she gets older she'll want more privacy but if you lay an early foundation of support it will help to build her self-confidence and give her the knowledge of a safe haven in you. Pay attention to any unusual changes in behavior that may involve her sleeping or eating habits.


If it comes to your attention that your daughter is the victim of a mean girl or group, don't be afraid to discuss the issue with the teachers or others in charge. You can't manage what you can't see so get other responsible adults involved. Make sure your child knows that it is OK to report what is going on and in fact necessary. Rehearse scripts with her so that she is prepared for the unkind words or being excluded. Encourage her to play with other "nicer" kids and help her do this by arranging play dates with the parents of those children. If she is too old for your involvement in "play dates" talk to her about having plans with some new girlfriends and what fun activities they can do together. Help her build her resources.


As counterintuitive as it may be, talk to your child about why someone would chose to be mean and hurtful. Explain to her that those children usually have a great deal of sadness in them and have a very hard time being empathetic or feeling someone else's pain. Somewhere in their life (usually at home) they feel very out of control and therefore they get some satisfaction by being in control of others. They may be either neglected in some way or (as is often the case) overindulged. Let her know that it doesn't excuse the behavior but it may explain it a bit. This is a way that you can build your own child's empathy which is such a valuable attribute. Be careful not to be too insistent that she not play with a "mean girl" because you don't want to make that child the forbidden fruit that your child must have. Try to subtly help your child unwind themselves from a person or group of kids that has these cruel tendencies by giving her alternatives.


If you happen to become aware of that fact that your child may be the perpetrator of these mean deeds then you will hopefully address the behavior immediately. Take a good look at what is going on at home. Children imitate what they see and the apple usually doesn't fall far from the tree. Even though it may seem like your child is happy, because they are in a position of power, they will most likely (and hopefully) get their comeuppance in due time. As painful as it may be you really do want your child to learn from their negative behavior and sometimes that learning is difficult. Encourage your child to be inclusive and lead by example. While it may be extremely difficult, try to break up alliances that your child has that exacerbate her behaviors. If you notice these unkind traits, put your child in situations where they are new to the group or out of their comfort zone. This will force her to see what it feels like to be on the outside and hopefully serve to help build empathy. Lastly, if your child is resistant to change and unable to see how their behavior is hurtful then get some help from the outside. Talk to a therapist or a counselor and get some guidance to help your child become the best person she can be.



Displaying comments 18-1 of 18
18
Different interesting topic.
By ellaallison  Nov 17, 2008
17
Interesting topic. I was also a "victim" of mean girls as a child. Had a pretty hard time of it actually, especially given I was trying to cope with a history of serious medical issues at the same time but that was a long time ago. I've moved on. I'm now quite a spiritual (as opposed to religious) person and I've come to understand that I was a chosen target because I made myself one by reacting to them.

The mean girls in life are going to be who they are. Everyone in life travels their own path and everyone is at their own level of learning. Whether or not anyone has an impact on us and what kind it is, is ultimately up to us and the manner in which we choose to react to a given situation. We can either learn from what happens or we can carry a non-productive wound.

For me, I learnt that I didn't like it when folks were mean to me, so why would I think that anyone else would like it if I was mean to them. It hurt a lot at the time but my experiences with the mean girls in my life have made me a better person and so, instead of carrying a wound, I am grateful to them for giving me the opportunity to learn an important lesson about treating others with respect.

The Dalai Lama says that you should treat everyone you meet with compassion and he is right. Do you really know what anothers thoughts or feelings are if you are not initimate with the details of their life or are you just assuming? Assumptions usually make us feel better but are rarely based in fact.

If you want a non-spiritual response - always smile, be exceptionally nice to them and don't react to what they say or do, it takes the wind out of their sails. We are only the victim if we choose to be.
By RAAFBrat  Nov 13, 2008
16
Thank you for this write up. It was very informative and I am prone to think this mean syndrome leads to anti-social personality disorder.
It would help if everyone can start being given some time to just be appreciated and valued in life. Many hearts are crying out especially in our youth and mean girl or boy syndrome will not make things any better.
By Caeli  Nov 11, 2008
15
I have four year old girl, that sometimes behave like a mean girl, but other times the victim of other girls. Yesterday she was punished since she hit other girls, so she was made to ask sorry. However when I talked to her, she told me that the other girl told her that she cannot be and play with girls in the group and she was mean to my daughter... I don't know, I spoke about no hitting with my child, but I did not offer anything instead hitting, talking to teacher, but the teachers in her room generally not very attentive and kind of straightforward. I don't know how to talk about it with four year old.
By gluzanna  Nov 11, 2008
14
Sadly, people face adult bullies as well. Liars, not tolerated in the real world, yet championed by some for getting away with a myriad of lies, big and small. It is pathetic that people must tear down real, caring, kind people, and build a fantasy to sell others so they appear interesting since real-lifers would not associate with them. No place is immune now. Happily, on here one can dissociate themselves quickly and easily, and move on happily to better people. Worthwhile, supportive, and truthful folks are much healthier to live with.
By Shazzashazza  Nov 09, 2008
13
In reading the last paragraph I must comment here. My child is a mean girl whose behavior is supported by my mother. My daughter decided at 14 that she was in charge and went to all lengths to accomplish that. My mother, instead of supporting me as a parent decided she would rather have my daughter like her so she supported the horrible bullying behavior of my daughter which put me in the middle. My daughter went so far as to claim that I was abusing her and took me to court. Again my mother was there to support her. This needless to say devistated me. My daughter is now 28 yrs old and still acts like that horrible 14 yr old and I no longer speak to my mother. The only contact I have with my daughter is when she is yelling at me, cursing me out and when I ask her why she does this, what did I do to her for her to harbor so much hate, she just flips out and starts calling me names. I spent much money, time and efforts with therapy for her, children's groups, family therapy, individual therapy but nothing helped. She has also turned on my son and he no longer wants to have contact with her abusive ways. My mother and her (pot head) father continue to support her behavior and treat her like a queen. I have begun to feel there is no hope here and my sweet little girl was only a brief encounter with this adult child who only gets worse as she gets older. I no longer believe people when they tell me she will grow out of it and realize her ways and come home to me. I can't even believe I gave birth to such a person but it is the fact of my life. She recently had a lavish very expensive wedding and she made it a point to leave me out, my mother proudly (evil as she is) acted the part of family for my daughter. Last week on my birthday began a 3 day campaign of abusive text messages from my daughter to myself until I finally had to disconnect my phone. I did nothing to spur this, she is now an out of control mean woman who I do not know. Needless to say these recent events have pushed me into full blown symptoms of my formerly controlled fibromyalgia, the stress still devistates me despite my attemts to ignore what has happened in my life with my daughter and my mother.
I guess my point is that this is a good article but sometimes the mean girl syndrom cannot be stopped or curtailed. The only way this happens and continues is because of the support and allowence of this mean behavior. The efforts to stop it has to be done by more than just the parent. Parents and other involved adults have to work together to stop this behavior and be supportive of each other instead of support the child no matter what she does. This is a key I believe to stopping this behavior. Today too many parents are afraid of their kids and cater to them and this lack of adult parenting allows for bad behavior that will often times last a life time and we have created a generation of mean, unmannered, self-centered, spoiled girls who never grow up.
By desrtrse  Nov 09, 2008
12
I was targeted first by my abusive family, in this case my mother and my sisters. She enjoyed tormenting me which influenced my sisters, two in particular, to follow suit. The technical term for it is triangulation and this scenario repeated itself throughout my early school years. I would be friends with two mutual friends and one day they would decide they didn't want to be my friend anymore. They'd confront me and say cruel things. My two sisters would taunt me mercilessly and continually exclude me. I still have the scars and sometimes think that we haven't really changed. In times of stress they seem to revert back to that behavior but its much more subtle. Or maybe I just handle it better and know instinctively to avoid them. It got to the point when I was in high school I didn't really have any friends. Now that I'm older I've gone through periods where I had friends who were more like acquaintances but the close friendships I was involved in over the years seemed to be abusive to me and would end badly. I'm at a place where I'm beginning to look honestly at what the abusive bullying did to me and see that it was extremely damaging. I don't have any friends and have no desire to try to develop any because I think my selection process in choosing friends is really flawed. I want to eventually get to the point in my healing process where I can choose people to be my friends in an environment where there will be mutual caring and respect. Not to set myself up for any more abuse because that's what I was forced to believe I deserved.
By StillSearching  Nov 09, 2008
11
I remember reading a book some years back that was very helpful: "Raising Their Voices, The Politics of Girls' Anger" or something like that.

Some of these mean kids might be growing up to have personality disorders. There might not be a hell of a lot that can be done to cure them at this point. Just giving them a wide berth whenever possible is the best course of action.
By Janthina  Nov 09, 2008
10
My sister was and still is a 'mean girl' so is my sister-in-law. Thank you for helping me understand them better and confirming the best course of action is avoidance (a bit hard at times when its family).
By Friend4  Nov 09, 2008
9
Those mean girls should be brought to a juvenile detention center to hear stories of what these girls are going through in their lives. The girls I have worked with have horrible lives, tragedy, addicted parents, kids, family members dying in their arms. Let them get a dose of the real world and learn how their horrible spoiled brat attitudes are shameful and rediculous and nothing to be proud of. They should all be forced to do community service in homeless shelters or battered women's shelters and get a dose of what is important in life. They are bullies and their eyes need to be open to reality.
By desrtrse  Nov 08, 2008
8
This article is very well written and extremely interesting. I wonder how much of what is stated transcends into adulthood and it is now manifested on other more popular social networks where young people congregate.

I was the target of a "mean group" and in fact I was derided by my own family members as to why I chose to distance myself from persons of that character. Basically, I avoided that lunacy as a child where it only worsened to more hideous gossip about me. But for some reason I never listened to the gossip, because I know if I did, my depression worsen and self-esteem decreased.

I think those of us who were early targets made great strides and found coping mechanisms to move forward as we grew into our adulthood. But maybe those us that suffered as late targets still have unclosed wounds.

Dr. G-
By AKAMonet  Nov 08, 2008
7
From what I see through my daughters 5 year old girlfriends, there is a touch of mean girl in all of them.
By Anna000  Nov 08, 2008
6
You have that right. Include bullyijng among adults,at work, in family ,and in any group that meets as a group.
i have been a "Target" and it took years to recover. Good Job mur
By mur  Nov 08, 2008
5
I was a Nineties girl in the Fifties and consequently was bullied and browbeaten by not only the Popular Girls but by the relentless pressure of a fifties mom and teachers who told me that girls could never be anything but nurses, teachers, mommies or if they were too stupid to go to college, secretaries. I would watch very carefully for signs as to WHY your daughter was being bullied and excluded and see if your unrealistic expectations of her have allied you with her tormentors. You may well believe that your pressure and *suggestions* that she be more like the girls who are tormenting and excluding her -- because her Popularity would increase your own Popularity, or because you were not Popular and you desperately want to re-live your life through a Popular daughter, or simply because you believe all girls belong in the same box and by God your daughter is going in that box even if you have to cut off her arms and legs to get her in there -- may be driving her to desperation. I was a tomboy who was interested in cars, sports and music and who was once accused of not having read a book because I could not describe the prom dresses, although I could tell the teacher every detail about the hotrod the boys were building; Mama wanted Suzy Sorority from the Silent Majority and never failed to express her disappointment with my accomplishments because the Popular Girls did not win reading and spelling contests on a regional level, did not know what gearbox ratio was and could not tell a Ferrari from a foxhole, so my knowing and doing these things was an embarrassment to her.

Mama is shocked to this very day to hear that she was treating me like a giraffe at an ant-eater picnic; she was never mean or unkind, but just so terribly disappointed. (Her other trick was to dismiss my accomplishment with *[your Popular sister] could do that!*) And she is 81 and I am 60. These things last a lifetime. So when your daughter is being harassed and mistreated by teachers and Popular Girls, examine your own behaviour carefully and see if you are in fact supporting the wrong team.
By Appleby  Nov 08, 2008
4
You have described my very own sister to a tee. And parents catered to her. Why?

My nice sister and I have always wanted to know what mental illness drives this erratic behavior and why parents would be so afraid that they would harm other children, love them less in order to keep the "mean girl" that you describe happy at all times.
By catlovesdi  Nov 08, 2008
3
Yes I was the victim of the mean girls, and it was encouraged by the teacher we had at the time in retribution to a stand my family had taken about the school and how things were done. My years there were absolute torture. I finally got away from them when I was sent to a different high school.
Then I found that same sort of behaviour on DS where several friends, supposedly really good friends, of mine told me that if I were friends with XXXX then they were not going to be friends of mine. That hurt, hurt a lot to find it is still rife in the adult females too. But as I am an adult now as well I just took the attitude of "don't let the door hit you, where the good Lord split you, on the way out." But surely you would think that adults would be a bit more mature than that wouldn't you? Did bring back the painful memories of growing up there for a bit though.
By Hathani  Nov 08, 2008
2
i was one of those mean girls because i was emotionally abused and neglected and sexually molested as a very young child.I also had no bonds with my mother, so i wanted someone else to hurt like i did.
Now looking back i wish i could apologize to the little girl i was mean to.I think a lot of children that are bullies are hurting themselves.
Although is no excuse, the bullies parents are partly responsible.
By amiko  Nov 08, 2008
1
Thank you for this. I had my own experiences as a young girl and I remember how horrible it felt.

When my daughter was in the 4th or 5th grade, I noticed one of her best friends exhibit some really strange behavior while at my house. She would go through my make-up and my jewelry! Also, if she didn't get her way, she would either play alone and ignore my daughter, or go off and hide somewhere, which made my daughter upset and cry. She also made up wild stories...

As time went on, I started wishing they would stop being friends. Of course, my child didn't want to hear anything bad about her friend, and I didn't want her repeating anything either, so I had to be really very careful about what I said. I told her my stories of knowing mean girls who were supposedly friends, but who whould always do or say hurtful things to me. Somehow, at my young age, I realized that they were acting that way because of some hurt they were feeling. So, instead of lashing out and possibly hurting the other person even more, I always just tried to ignore it and look for people to be friends with who were not hurtful.

My daughter began a friendship with another girl that I really liked a lot, but of course the "mean" girl couldn't stand for that. She weazled her way over to our house every time the other girl was over. My daughter had come up with a little club for the 3 of them and she had planned it all out for them. She was a very out-going and positive child - up until this. That "mean" girl eventually "took away" the other girl and made up stories about my daughter. They had planned a "club meeting" for a Saturday and my daughter was so excited about it. An hour before the meeting, they called her and told her they wanted her to come up to one of the other girl's house instead of them coming to our house. When she got there, they told her they didn't want her in THEIR club anymore!

She was crushed... It was so hard to watch this happening to my child. Like, I said, she used to be very outgoing and it really changed her. She is much more cautious now - which really isn't a bad thing!

Turns out that the "mean" girl's parents were really having some severe marriage problems (substance abuse, plus physical abuse) and they ended up divorcing about a year later. I suspect she had learned a lot of her "control" habits from them. She and the other girl did not stay buddies for very long, but my daughter never would trust the other girl again. So, they are all just acquaintances now, all living in the same neighborhood...
By cmcjiff  Nov 07, 2008
Got a Question?
 
 
 
 
My Fans
POPULAR POSTS